BehindMLM’s State of the Scam [2024]
Today on April 10th, 2024, BehindMLM turns fourteen.
This is a look back on the past twelve months, published as our annual “State of the Scam” report.
MLM crypto scams
I won’t waste your time trying to analyze the perpetually manipulated state the crypto market is in (lol tether), but I started to notice a decline in MLM crypto schemes around Q4 last year.
It was gradual at first. New launches weren’t sticking and the average lifespan of an MLM crypto scam dropped to one to two months.
There was also a distinct lack of “mega Ponzis”, something we’d seen consistently over years past. OmegaPro was probably the last mega-Ponzi I tracked and that collapsed towards the end of 2022.
Just so there’s no ambiguity, when I say “mega Ponzi” I’m referring to a scheme that tops monthly website visits of a few million (this is typically the peak of a mega Ponzi).
In fact for most of 2023 to date, there hasn’t been a prominent mega Ponzi to report on.
Outside of some diehard Russians still launching the odd Boris CEO, and what’s left of the scammers who thought AI was going to be the next big grift, MLM crypto scamming, at least for now, is pretty much dead.
This is a bit of a surprise with the current pump manipulation of the wider crypto market but I guess not totally unexpected. Outside of dwindling echo chambers there’s little to no new interest in crypto in general.
Will it stick throughout 2024? That I’m uncertain of. We’re coming up on or around six months now and it’s pretty quiet. Without knowing the specific contributors forecasting the rest of the year is difficult.
Broadly speaking I think one of the primary contributors to MLM crypto schemes imploding is people just don’t have money to lose. Secondary to that could be the ongoing various high-profile crypto busts out of the US.
Anyway BehindMLM will of course keep reviewing the MLM crypto schemes that pop up, but it’s also refreshing to have more time for the rest of the MLM industry as well.
Pending an uptick in MLM crypto fraud, by about mid year the balance should be at around 50% between MLM crypto and non-crypto coverage.
The MLM industry in general
In line with the decline in MLM crypto schemes, there’s also an overall contraction of the MLM industry.
Non-crypto MLM launches have never been prolific but we’re seeing mergers and acquisitions take place.
I don’t typically focus on how MLM companies are doing but I do recall the odd time I’ve pulled up website statistics as part of general research there’s an overall trend towards decline.
Launches are smaller and initial hype fizzles out quicker. Top distributors are getting restless and switching companies to try and reestablish lost earnings.
There’s been two or three instances over the past year where dwindling earnings have been cited as a defense for alleged cross-recruitment. Pruvit’s failure to pay executives is another example that comes to mind.
Long term the MLM industry might bounce back but over the next year I anticipate we’ll see more bankruptcies and top distributor earnings squabbling.
BehindMLM housekeeping
Being a publication that researches and reports on the MLM, we’re not immune to the industry downturn.
Online publishing in general across the internet is in a bad spot and we’re grouped in with that as well.
We’re OK for now but at some point I might need to pivot. I’m trying not to plan too far ahead and for the most part will just play it by ear.
I’ve always maintained I’ll continue to publish on BehindMLM as long as there’s reader demand. That hasn’t changed.
Outside of MLM and online publishing being in a slump the other concern is still frivolous legal proceedings initiated by GSPartners and Josip Heit.
I covered this in depth last year but, long story short, proceedings are still playing in the background.
As silly as it might seem for GSPartners and Heit to maintain intention to sue for defamation when they hold the record for regulatory fraud warnings (thirteen US states, six Canadian provinces and four other countries), that’s the ruse they’re sticking to.
Looking forward, there’s a hearing on our filed appeal on May 8th with oral arguments.
The outcome of that hearing will see one of two scenarios play out;
If the appeal is upheld, proceedings will be punted back to the New York Supreme Court. Our legal counsel has informed the Appeal Court if that happens we intend to initiate anti-SLAPP proceedings.
Regulatory fraud warnings render any claims of defamation from Heit and GSB Gold Standard Corporation DOA. This has never been anything more than a fishing expedition.
Alternatively our appeal isn’t successful, in which case the only immediate change will be security on my end. Given Heit’s proximity to organized crime interests in Europe, extrajudicial retaliation remains a primary concern.
Law enforcement and regulators are briefed and observing. And it’s expected federal civil and criminal charges in the US will drop at some point.
The way I see it, at some point you have to acknowledge you’ve done everything you can and just get on with it. I’m not the first journalist to be targeted and I won’t be the last.
Thanks for reading for another year. Next year BehindMLM turns fifteen!
Passing along my best wishes for your appeal being upheld and subsequent litigation.
I’ve been bitching about scams online in one form or another since 2006. You my friend have a dedication I lack and I greatly respect you for it.
Here’s looking forward to many more anniversaries and if it all works out in the courts, a hefty anti-slapp settlement from Mr. Heit.
Thank you for all the effort, much appreciated!
<3
One thing I forgot to touch on further was the use of AI in MLM crime.
As it stands I’m still able to detect the use of AI in marketing videos and to a lesser extent photos (I just assume if there’s a photo of someone with no corresponding footprint it’s an AI generated image).
I’m not keeping a super close eye on it but tech companies keep releasing newer AI tools to make scamming people with easier. There’s typically a lag while this trickles down to scammers (our MLM variety aren’t generally particularly intelligent), but there will probably be a time when I have to just put up a “this might be AI” warning on our reviews.
Don’t know if that will happen over the next twelve months but if you start seeing an AI message (it’ll be similar to our Dubai fraud message), assume it’s gotten to the point where I can’t make a reasonable determination.
Unfortunately if it gets to that point consumers are going to have no hope in hell but distrust with AI is growing (outside of the boomer demographic). One side-effect of this is people are far more likely to write off something as an AI scam.
I unfortunately can’t just default that to that as I have a bar to clear but like I said previously, if it gets to the point where I can’t distinguish on face value I’ll have to take other factors into consideration and make a call.
This will be an individual process on each review. Unlike the Dubai warning I can’t see a scenario where detection of AI = blanket scam. At least not yet.
Thank you for your hard work, Oz!
If the lawsuit fails and the bushes outside your house suddenly start to get tattoos and speak Romanian then run! D:
Thank you for your hard work, Oz. I found your website after a family member put a large chunk of retirement savings into what looked to me like an obvious scam (Daisy).
Sadly, I was unable to convince them to bail out completely, but I’m glad SOMEONE on the interwebs is doing something to limit the damage these scammers do.
Happy Anniversary! Wishing you the best for all your dedication and wonderful work over the years.
May you not only have success and be vindicated in this current case, but hopefully the scammers will face justice for all of their malintent.
I wish you the best for everything, Oz. Your work has a positive impact.
Your professionalism in this field is unequalled; thank you Oz.
When I am asked questions about X company and if I do not know the answer off the top of my head, your website is my first stop.
I greatly appreciate the work you do as I find it invaluable to the fight against unethical business practices, and to me, MLM fits that mark.
I also appreciate commenters because their insight has provided more information in whichever rabbit hole I am down at a particular moment in time. I thank you.
I am hoping for the best on May 8th.
thank you sir. SB
thank you for your work Oz!
Thank you, Oz, for all you do and will be doing in the future.
We are forever hopeful that the new regulations in force here in the United Kingdom will plug the hole in company registrations by fraudsters.
In 2023 we still saw almost one million new companies registered in Britain.
Plus the new Financial Conduct Authority legal muscle to clamp down on crypto scams.
It is an ongoing fight to keep people safe, but I can confirm even my Facebook groups are seeing fewer scams being shared.
So maybe a turn for the better?
Keep well, and keep doing the good.
Hopefully you will continue to out scammers like Ed Zimbardi, Erich Ely, Scott Morris, Michael Zavits, Wayne Nash, Mike Dwyer, Jim Wear, Tara Hirshberg and any other scumbag promoters. Keep up the good work.
Thanks for keeping up the great work I hope that the day you decide to stop writing on that topic, someone as talented will take over the reins! Long live behindmlm.
Just a personal update;
One of my dogs was diagnosed with a suspected nasal tumor ~Feb 2023. She was 12 so I opted for palliative care.
After an initial nose bleed in Feb 2023, she was symptom free till about the same time this year (~Feb 2024). Nothing serious but the odd spot of blood now and again.
She’s not in any pain and is otherwise fine but as of a few weeks ago it’s restricting airflow through her nose. A CT confirmed this. Now it’s starting to affect her sleep.
I’m taking each day at a time but workwise my mind is elsewhere. There’s some reviews ready to go but it might be hit and miss for a bit.
She turns 13 next month. She’s the loyalest, goodest girl and my heart is breaking.
I need some time but didn’t want to alarm anyone if things got a bit quiet this coming week.
Sorry Oz, family first always, even the furry ones.
Thanks. Does my head in sometimes trying to manage elderly pets and BMLM.
So sorry to hear this news. My wife’s cockatiel of 22 years died. We knew she was dying so we did have time to prepare for it, but still you aren’t totally prepared.
Since we have another cockatiel, we had to find another bird or he would have gone into depression, which they can’t treat. Thankfully we found one that we got the following week after our Nico had died. Still feel the pain of her loss, but the new bird really helps ease the pain.
Rule of thumb for all of Eagle’s volunteers was 1. family (including pets), 2. job, 3. church and then what time available to volunteer with Eagle. Was blessed with 20 years of service from our volunteers.
Thanks Lynn. Wow, twenty-two years. I can only imagine the hole that left.
Thankfully my two dogs aren’t bonded. They tolerate each other but aren’t reliant, so stress on the other pup is minimal if at all.
I’ll probably get another cat at some point. Still miss my little guy sorely after he passed a few years ago.
Makes you wonder why we bother but the time together all things considered is priceless.
My apologies for not celebrating your Anniversary of behindMLM. Your service has been invaluable in the fight against these criminals and helping people from becoming victims.
You are the go-to forum for law enforcement for information and critical resources they can use in court against these criminals. Your site is truly a repository of valuable information and content.
You deserve all the accolades you receive. My deepest appreciation for all you do, and here’s to many more years of service to us all.
All good Lynn, thanks for reading!