South Africa to criminally investigate TVI Express
As we draw to the close of 2010, another major blow has been dealt to TVI Express’ operations in Africa.
On the 29th of December, 2010, South Africa’s Department of Trade and Industry not only officially confirmed TVI has been declared a pyramid scheme in South Africa, but also that they intended to launch criminal proceedings against the company and its distributors.
The Department of Trade and Industry said yesterday it had opened a police case against TVI Express “for operating a prohibited Pyramid Promotional Scheme”.
“This matter was reported to SAPS Commercial Crime Unit in Durban in September for further investigation and prosecution,” said Trade and Industry spokesperson Sidwell Medupe.
The scheme contravened Notice 1135 of 1999 promulgated in terms of the provisions of Consumer Affairs (Unfair Business Practices) Act 71 of 1988.”
According to South Africa’s Consumer Affairs Act,
Persons are not directly permitted to, directly or indirectly, promote or knowingly join, enter into or participate in pyramid schemes (receiving compensation, primarily from the respective recruitment of other participants).
As seems to be the continued trend now with TVI Express and regulatory action against it, the company has chosen to not respond to any of the allegations made against it.
Instead TVI Express have completely abandoned their operations in South Africa and left those involved in the company facing the risk of criminal prosecution.
In speaking to the media, South African TVI Express member Bongi Ngomane stated
The owner of the scheme, Parun Trika from India, has disappeared and the website that was used to purchase the vouchers has been closed.
We have tried to contact him through our main communication line – the website – but only get a reply that the scheme is on hold as he has to verify our virtual offices.
With the seriousness of the allegations made against TVI in South Africa and a lack of an official response thus far, it’s easy to see how South African TVI members might feel like Trika has disappeared. More likely I believe however is he’s simply chosen to cut all ties with South Africa and concentrate on promoting TVI elsewhere.
As for the website, I presume Ngomane is talking about some sort of localised version of the international TVI Express website. I thought these were simply funnels that directed traffic to the international back end but I could be wrong.
In any case, stating that he had to ‘verify‘ the South African virtual offices is a bit rich coming from Trika. A virtual office doesn’t have a physical location so short of confirming it’s functional, what else is there to verify.
More than likely I believe Trika knew something was up in South Africa and put the establishment of TVI virtual offices in the country indefinitely on hold.
If you have an office in a country, even a virtual office, then there’s a paper trail for authorities to follow leading to the top. Obviously if you’re running a pyramid scheme it’s much more convenient to simply let your members claim to be leaders within the company and stand on their own.
That way if the shit hits the fan, as it appears to have happened in South Africa, you can simply cut and run.
Meanwhile over in neighbouring Namibia similar regulatory action appears to be underway against TVI Express. Last I heard TVI Express had been declared an illegal pyramid scheme by the Bank of Namibia, TVI members were threatening a class action lawsuit against the government and, as far as I can tell, there’s been no official response from TVI itself.
In light of the complete abandonment of TVI Express’ South African members following regulatory action, if I was marketing TVI Express in Namibia I’d be seriously thinking about a career change.
Really, so Tarun Trikha (i.e. Parun Trika) is still around TVI Express? In November his name disappeared from the “Advisory Board”, and before that he was called “owner and CEO” by various TVI Express unofficial websites.
Six months ago, when Ted Nuyten / Businessforhome.org published an expose on TVI Express and Tarun Trikha, the site was taken down by a DDOS attack.
http://www.mlmhelpdesk.com/2010/06/01/ted-nuyten-reports-tvi-express-is-behind-the-freedom-of-speech-ddos-attack-at-business-for-home/
TVISmart, a Thai TVI Express site, posted a picture of the major leaders of TVI Express (at the time) meeting. Guess where? In a McDonalds:
http://kschang.blogspot.com/2010/05/confirmed-tvi-express-fan-manipulated.html
And someone was removed from the picture… very badly.
Maybe we should call TVI Express CutLossesAndRun Express…
They “allegedly” hired attorneys to defend Team TVI Oz in Australia… and the trial was supposed to be long over. Neither side announced anything. You’d think if they “won” they’d announce something.
They “allegedly” hired Grimes and Reese in the US, but there was no confirmation and TVINorthAmerica got slapped with Cease and Desist, and Patrik Dejour immediately escalated it to TVI Corporate… and got no response. No lawyer to defend it, so now TVI Express is banned in Georgia.
And now… South Africa. Cut and run again.
And thus far nobody is defending it in Indonesia, where they have been declared haram (unclean for Muslims) and money game (i.e. pyramid scheme) except its members, who are busy making up excuses.
TVI Express declared haram and Money game in Indonesia
http://translate.google.com/translate?hl=en&u=http%3A%2F%2Fserambinews.com%2Fnews%2Fview%2F44534%2Fmpu-haramkan-money-game
TVIExpresDollar/Rudy Phan claims TVI Express halal even though he’s not even a Muslim!
http://kschang.blogspot.com/2010/12/as-predicted-rudy-phan-posted-bull.html
TVI Express highlighted on PatrickPretty.com Ponzi Scheme Alert Site, joins MPB Today and Data Network in using Warren Buffett picture without permission
http://www.patrickpretty.com/2011/01/02/like-mpb-today-and-data-network-affiliates-promoters-tvi-express-pitchmen-used-images-of-warren-buffet-and-donald-trump-government-of-south-africa-reportedly-opens-criminal-probe-amid-pyramid-alle/
TVI Express Lured in Police Chief of Java Indonesia a while back, no wonder so many Indonesians taken in by scam
http://kschang.blogspot.com/2011/01/tvi-express-used-police-chief-to.html
Indonesian News Says TVI Express is Deceptive Business
http://translate.googleusercontent.com/translate_c?hl=en&sl=id&u=http://www.tribunnewsbatam.com/2010/09/29/mlm-tvi-expres-makan-korban-di-tanjungpinang&prev=/search%3Fq%3D%2522TVI%2BExpress%2522%2BACCC%26start%3D150%26hl%3Den%26safe%3Doff%26sa%3DN%26rlz%3D1B3GGLL_enUS400US400%26tbas%3D0%26prmd%3Divns&rurl=translate.google.com&twu=1&usg=ALkJrhgD-JQzEv1re7bg3dPvDLKu2fQoWw
Here’s a bit more revelation… In December TVI Express requested all members to “verify” their membership.
Turns out they are requiring every member to upload a COLOR COPY of their government ID.
http://translate.googleusercontent.com/translate_c?hl=en&sl=id&u=http://www.tviexpressdollar.com/verifikasi-akun-member-tvi-express-supaya-duit-anda-aman/&prev=/search%3Fq%3D%2522TVI%2BExpress%2522%26start%3D10%26hl%3Den%26safe%3Doff%26sa%3DN%26rlz%3D1B3GGLL_enUS400US400%26tbs%3Dqdr:d%26prmd%3Divnsl&rurl=translate.google.com&twu=1&usg=ALkJrhh46rp7QYY1mWvtjNkDhRXjs80AIA
Not sure why I can’t seem to post any updates… try again…
Item 1) In December, TVI Express suddenly request all users to “verify” their account. I then suspected this is a way they can invalidate eVouchers given out thus reducing “expenses”. Turns out the verification process is a MASSIVE invasion of privacy. How you ‘verify’ your account is by uploading a COLOR copy of your government ID to TVI Express.
http://kschang.blogspot.com/2011/01/rudy-phan-is-back-with-more-ridiculous.html
Item 2) TVI Express claims to be expanding into South Africa in 2011 in their January “newsletter”. Which is HILARIOUS when you take into account the above declaration from the South African government.
very informative information/ Although I don’t live in Africa, this is great to be informed concerning any businesses that comes out of there and is shown where we are living.
Thanks for keeping us informed.
susie moore
internet marketer
South Africa Reserve Bank joins TVI Express investigation along with South African police
http://www.thenewage.co.za/14436-1010-53-SARB_investigating_alleged_Ponzi_scheme
Cheers for that Kasey. The SARB news popped up on my radar Wednesday but had other stuff to write about. Did a full write up today on it.
Hi there Editor
I am also a victim of this TVI pyramid scheme. I paid my money to certain people, who represented TVI in JHB around Oct 2010.
I need to help the SA Police in this investigation. Do you know or have contacts of SAPS or DTI responsible people?
thank you.
As local police (in South Africa) have arrested people, I’d say just walk into police department and make a complaint, make sure you mention “TVI Express” and you should be able to talk to an investigator.
@Mavukuvuku
I’d suggest as Kasey suggested starting with your local police station. If that doesn’t work try contacting the South African Department of Trade or the South African Reserve Bank.
Good luck!
i dont see anything wrong about TVI. ATLEAST people are getting paid by tvi.
As i speak to you, south african government keep on saying vuka udzendzele, then people are doing something that the government cant do for them,that was part of ending suffering here in mzasi.
WHAT MORE DO YOU WANT? TO CREATE MORE CRIMINALS OR WHAT? HOW MANY PROSTITUTES IN MZANSI? HOW MANY CRIMINALS AND MORE ARE STILL TO HAPPEN,
@alexa — You don’t understand the difference between a legitimate MLM and a pyramid scheme.
In a legitimate MLM, things are SOLD, and VALUE is created. The only way it’s different from a normal business is the way marketing is done. In a legitimate MLM recruiting is done only very seldomly, as most people are NOT good salespeople, so you ONLY recruit the people who are.
In a fake MLM (such as TVI Express), there is nothing sold. It is all recruiting, and the people who got paid are paid from the $$$ paid in by the late comers. EVERYbody can join, and you can even BUY multiple positions (so you can push out the guy on top even faster).
Here are the differences
http://hubpages.com/hub/How-to-distinguish-a-Legitimate-MLM-from-a-Fake-MLM
@alexa-gp
The basis of whether or not TVI are paying their members does not negate or draw attention away from the fact that it’s simply just a giant recruitment scheme.
If you don’t see anything wrong with earning money by recruiting people who then have to go and do the same then you might be a lost cause (or extremely gullible).
As for criminals, ideally there should be less of them and by declaring TVI to be a pyramid scheme, that’s exactly what your government is setting out to achieve.
The greater irony here of course being that participating in TVI in South Africa is now illegal and anyone doing so is a criminal.
People turning to crime is not a valid justification to keep a known pyramid scheme in business. Get out there and find a legit opportunity if you want to work in MLM, or failing that something else which isn’t illegal to participate in.
sinnce i’ve join tvi last year i havent receive not even a single cent, whole 26000Rand is gone. Im very much upset about this………
Did you do anything after you joined the business?
mtha,if you havnt receive even a cent from tvi-express,who do u expect 2 give u payment,and why join tvi if you dont understand,this is an online business,you are the kind of pay-check people,you are in a wrong environment,people like you who wants to be spoon-feed,they will never make it.
guys is tvi true or not reason i don’t understand and do u get vouchers for hotels
Apparently you get vouchers for hotels but from what I understand these aren’t all inclusive. Nor do they cover airfares and other third party expenses.
TVI Express have been rather quiet lately so I’m not sure if anything’s changed.
In TVI Express, when you join, you get this “certificate” (with borders stolen from another website, and I can prove it) e-mailed to you with some code, which you need to type into their “redemption website”.
You have to choose from a special list of participating resorts and hotels (NOT the 95000 they are telling you about). THEN they will “approve” your request and give you some sort of confirmation.
The problem is, the confirmation is often faked. People in South Africa have reported instances where they show up at the hotel and was told there was no reservation, or there was a reservation but it was NOT PAID.
It was so bad, South Africa’s “Wealth Team” all jumped ship to a competitor after having several of their members “burned”. Then the government got involved…
http://www.thenewage.co.za/16342-1010-53-Pyramid_probe_goes_big
the other question is as individual u think i should join tvi reason is i’m trying to make a leaving for my kids what confuse me people says its working who has made reseaches or can testyfy if is working or not
The problem is: can you trust people who are telling you that it is working?
Their motive to tell you it is working is to get you to sign up, because they have to sign up people to get paid. That makes it a pyramid scheme, which is illegal everywhere.
If you wish to engage in illegal activity, then so do. But engaging in illegal activity while believing it to be legal only makes you… naive and stupid. I hope you are neither.
@quest
Don’t ask for ‘proofs’ or ‘testimonials’. A pyramid scheme will always be able to pay out money in the beginning, but it doesn’t mean that YOU will get paid. Most participants that join the scheme late will lose their money.
TVI Express have already been shut down by authorities in several countries. What more proofs do you need?
Why join a pyramid scheme if you want to create a living for your kids? You risk to lose it all even if you get paid. Once they have been shut down or have collapsed in one country the schemes become even more shortlived.
@chang
why do i get the feeling you have been a victim to this “scheme” as you call it. Seems to me like youre out to get tvi for what they did to you.
wel as tvi states on their website and presentation that this is not for everyone however those who chose tvi are requred to do as the business requires which is expanding the network. I think its not up to you to decide for people whether they join or not you should just voice your opinion as you are by all means entitled to it.
As for people who stil wanna join tvi i suggest you do the all necessary research and get frightened by one person who clearly has a vandeta with tviexpress….. however be very careful with these MLM some are by all means dangerous and wil con you of your money in a minute.
I for one have benefited from the network and ofcourse recommend it to others not that i wann a benefit from them but only that i want them to tast what i have tasted
excuse the spelling errors im using my phone
@em – what happened to me or not
1) is none of your business
2) has NO relevance on what I said / wrote
3) it ain’t about me
4) you’re trying to change the subject.
5) you can’t disprove anything I say, so you try to smear me.
6) I have voiced my opinion. When have I not done so?
7) Feel free to elaborate on how you “have benefited from the network”. If you mean you got paid, please explain what you have sold to make you deserve of such a reward.
If you only have recruited, please explain why it’s NOT a pyramid scheme.
More dire news for TVI Express:
1) Leading Consumer Action Group in Indonesia tells TVI Express to get out of town and stop cheating Indonesians
(link in Indonesian)
http://www.tribunnews.com/2011/07/25/dituding-money-games-hentikan-bisnis-tvi-express-di-indonesia
2) State Bank of Vietnam joins investigation of TVI Express as illegal investment scheme / pyramid scheme
(link in Vietnamese)
http://nld.com.vn/2011072210199977p0c1014/du-lich-kiem-tien-huy-dong-von-trai-luat.htm
TVI Express ignores bad news questions.
When questioned about lack of proper business license, the spokesman claims they only need to change their name and promote the correct name. How that fixes the license, they have no explanation. Only claim that it is an inconvenience.
http://translate.google.com/translate?hl=en&sl=id&u=http://www.reportasenews.com/&ei=kS0yTrKcFZDWiAKI6ei6CA&sa=X&oi=translate&ct=result&resnum=1&ved=0CDwQ7gEwADha&prev=/search%3Fq%3DTVI%2BEXPRESS%26start%3D90%26hl%3Den%26sa%3DN%26rlz%3D1C1GPCK_enUS321US322%26biw%3D1243%26bih%3D652%26tbs%3Dqdr:d%26prmd%3Divnsl
That is a lie. TVI express is not banned in South Africa, get your facts right before commenting.
When you arrest the ringleaders and the South African Department of Trade declares a company to be a pyramid scheme, which under South African law,
Then the company is effectively banned. Anyone promoting it is doing so at risk of prosecution.
tell me how do i lay a fraudulent charge against TVI representatives Nozuko Feni and Ntombomzi Mbuqu who robbed me of R100 000 through this TVI scam and never got a fraction of what they promised after 2 years
Head down to your local police station, they should be able to advise you.
Gans, pls make me understand. What are the facts here???, TVI is a scam period!!! I lost my hard earned money through this PYRAMID SCHEME. Otherwise how do you explain that after 2 years of investing my R100 000 i never got a cent back and yet you continue to claim that ppl get big returns in a short space of time. Perhaps short space of time = 100 years of which i’ll be dead by now and you’ll send my great great grandkids emails to claim their inheritance like 411 ??????
Thank you Oz. I wish this Nozuko Feni, her father and this thief Ntombomzi Mbuqu payback tenfold for what they did
Can you believe it, they even registered their company TVI SA and when you deposit the cash you are convinced they’ve got nothing to do with where the money is going
I just came home from a briefing invitation for TVI Express here in the Philippines! They started their operation here late 2011, have almost 45,000 members and the numbers are increasing.
I better warn these people, but they all seem so excited and gung ho about making money!!! 🙁
Not so much of a warning as just pointing out the obvious.
“I’m gunna make bajillions!”
“Yes but how, what are you actually going to do to earn it?”
“Recruit people into TVI Express!”
“…you don’t see the problem here?”
I’ve been warning Filipinos about TVI Express for months. I’ve been ignored… mostly.
I posted this public notice well over a year ago. Did any one notice? Nope.
http://www.gensansale.com/threads/do-not-join-tvi-express-scam-banned-in-many-countries.20149/
I really need help people! I’ve invested over R180 000 ($12 500) in TVI and followed each and every step – as I was told- to making money. Yes, I know it was trumendously stupid of me not to have performed thorough research about this company but right now I cannot dwell on that.
I’m desperately looking for solutions. I just want to take my money out! I’ve tried calling, e-mailing you name it! And it hasn’t worked! I’ve cycled out and I have not recieved a penny.
I am beyond hurt by this … Who could be so evil! The people that entered TVI Express under my family and I are equally as pissed off at tvi but even angrier at me. I am haunted by the phone calls of people who want their money! This has ruined my life to a point where I see no exit out of this but death. I’m crying as I type this.
I need anyone’s help right now, please (Ozedit: email removed) And to whoever wants join tvi, I’d personally like to say that that would be the most stupid thing you’d ever want to think of investing in.
Sorry to hear about your situation Marcus. Being a pyramid scheme and all your money is gone, unless you can wrangle it out of your upline (the person who recruited you).
its so confussing, just yesterday we were attending a presentation of TVI it was so interesting especially when you hear how people got the R 10800.00.
Its feels so sad cause people make loans to join TVI, i personally wont join cause i’ve been a victim of pyramid before so i know the pain though its tempting when you money in peoples accounts.
Iv joined tvi in july bcos my sister got R216000,00 in june nd july. I received R5200,00 once bcos the 2 people I recruited never got to recruit anyone therefore the whole team is stuck.
I would like to know the latest news on south african reserve bank investigations?
Local police are close to arrests, according to your local papers back in July:
http://www.iol.co.za/business/business-news/sa-s-biggest-pyramid-scheme-exposed-1.1351696#.UBoOQWEe5Lo
I was advised by a person who recruited me to TVI Express to invest lump sum of money so that my investment will multiply to fivefold within a month or two. Until now I never received even a cent.
I have invested R230 000 in July 2010. Is there anyway to claim back my money since these scammers are arrested?
@Buli
The only advice I can offer is get in touch with the local authorities who arrested “the scammers”.