Receivership filing details Scoville’s non-cooperation (Traffic Monsoon)
In a Facebook post dated August 23rd, Charles Scoville told Traffic Monsoon affiliates that
the SEC has taken away everything I own; making me basically homeless, penniless, and near powerless to defend myself.
Perhaps not so surprisingly, a new filing from the Traffic Monsoon Receiver reveals Scoville wasn’t entirely truthful.
Back in early August the Receiver raised the prospect of using seized funds to pay for Scoville and his family to return to the US. At the time they were living in the UK.
Pending negotiations, the court approved the Receiver’s motion and ordered a report filed by September 15th.
Yesterday the Receiver filed that report, claiming Scoville in the end did not request funds to return to the US.
Early negotiations between the Receiver and Scoville saw the Receivership offer to
make arrangements to pay travel and living expenses from the Receivership Estate provided he cooperated with the Receiver by:
(a) providing information about a foreign financial account that Scoville had not previously disclosed, and to which Scoville caused several million dollars to be wired during the month leading up to the filing of this case;
(b) providing a copy of a lease agreement on a London flat said to be leased in his new spouse’s name, on which Scoville had arranged one year of rent to be prepaid;
(c) turning over keys to a flat titled in Scoville’s name located in Manchester, England;
(d) turning over a Ranger Rover that was purchased with over $125,000.00 from Scoville’s bank account in May, 2016 and titled in his wife’s name;
(e) providing proof of insurance on the Range Rover and a Nissan located in Murray, Utah; and
(f) turning over a laptop computer in Scoville’s possession for a short period so that an image could be obtained by the Receiver.
To put all of that into context, poor penniless and homeless Scoville had accommodation in both the US and UK he had prepaid leases on for a year, a car in the UK recently purchased for over $100,000, two cars in the US and millions of dollars stashed in a previously undisclosed offshore account.
Oh, the humanity!
Ultimately negotiations between Scoville and the Receiver broke down.
Scoville failed to submit ‘a budget for travel expenses‘ and his cooperation regarding the above requests was limited.
Scoville provided proof of insurance as requested and screen shots of transactions related to the wiring of funds to the foreign financial account (which did nothing more than show part of what the Receiver had previously shared with Scoville’s counsel about the transactions).
He also informed the Receiver about several possible London addresses at which she might locate the Range Rover, and indicated that he did not have possession of the lease agreement to the London flat or the keys to the Manchester flat.
Otherwise, Scoville did not cooperate with the Receiver.
Upon arriving in the US by means unknown, Scoville contacted the Receiver and demanded a “living allowance”.
The Receiver agreed to review a budget, providing Scoville ‘cooperated by at least providing information about the foreign financial account‘.
To date Scoville has not provided information about the offshore account he has millions stashed in. Nor has he filed a budget for living expenses.
By permission of the Receiver, Scoville and his son are currently staying in the Utah apartment he’d prepaid the lease on. Scoville also has use of a Nissan in his name, provided he maintains insurance on the vehicle.
The exact figure Scoville wired offshore in the months prior to the SEC filing is currently unknown. Ditto the whereabouts of his wife, Samera Hussain (aka Semera Hussain).
A few days ago Scoville ditched attorney Edwin S. Wall and signed up with D. Loren Washburn of Washburn Law Group, LLC.
In a Facebook post made a few hours ago, Shirley Scoville, Charles Scoville’s mother, claims Washburn Law Group charge “higher fees”.
If one wanted to learn what NOT to do when shut down by the SEC, they would need to look no further than at Charles Scoville.
It’s like a fact pattern given in a law school exam. Good grief!
SEC investigations are hard for lawyers when the clients think they can outsmart everyone. They always end up digging themselves into a deeper hole.
Good time to revisit the quote from Charlie’s “mom” that anjali included on the previous post.
The receiver’s report doesn’t seem to portray Charles as being the “innocent law-abiding businessman” mom claims him to be.
Makes you wonder whether Charlie is the only Scoville scammer or if it’s more of a family affair. Will be interesting to see how much each member of the Scoville family sucked out of Charlie’s TM ponzi scheme.
whaaaat!
lying thieving scoville posted on sept 7, 2016:
everything this fellow says is a LIE.
he’s playing his affiliates, so that he can squeeze a few last bucks from them and pretend to the court that he is being unfairly treated by the SEC.
just send the damn guy to jail man!
if i were to guess, i’d say samera hussain is young and was not fully aware of what a ponzi is. she was making very good money from TM [in dec 2015 she had posted that she had a 6 (or 7) figure income from TM at the age of 27], and was probably infatuated with scoville as he was the source of her fortune.
like many scammers are, scoville was probably very charming and convinced her that his business was legit.
the SEC action probably made her question her blind faith in scoville, and she may have left him and returned to the safety of her family and gone off the radar.
if she married scoville in some sort of a secret muslim ceremony, without registering the marriage in the UK, then they are not ‘legally’ married and she wont require a ‘divorce’ from him?
as far as i know, a muslim cannot marry a non muslim under muslim law, so maybe scoville adopted islam to be able to marry her?
It sounds all very highschool to me. Anyway I’m sure we’ll find out what went down in good time.
Interesting that Kevin Thompson is now commenting, when he (Ozedit: Offtopic derail attempt removed)
When the intention is to firstly take away Scovilles’ money and possessions, then fine his ass so he can hardly afford to breathe, followed by metaphorically nailing his hide to the wall, the smart thing to do is to allow him to use up every constitutional and legal right available to him so there can be no argument once the cell door closes.
With all the excuses and theories which follow the closure of a HYIP ponzi / pyramid, it’s easy to forget the guy has been publicly running a multi million dollar US based fraudulent scheme in 2016 and he’s not going to simply walk away.
The best he can hope for is that he’ll get to stall things for a month here and there and be able to see a couple more Christmases before his sentence begins.
He sure as h*** ain’t gonna “win” anything else
Would I be correct in saying, at least for now, there are no criminal charges?
No criminal charges yet.
Innocent until proven guilty or at least that’s supposed to be the procedure however the US has done some radical law changes in the last decade under Obama that now allows the authorities to arrest someone without probable cause where they can be held for as long as they want without needing to provide any evidence as to why they were arrested in the first place.
In the SECs case however it’s doubtful Obama ever got around to screwing with that process.
The SEC only brings civil charges. The DOJ would be the one filing criminal charges eventually.
Charles in his latest rant has called the Receiver a liar. Real brilliant move Charles So much for people thinking you are a genius.
God you truly are more stupid than I gave you credit for, but thanks.
For those of you who may have missed Charles’ latest post on his FB page, here it is and I quote:
Charles you have to stop saying God Willing, God Guide, God knows or people will believe your conversion to Islam was all a lie. But I loved the part where he is trying to convince his members that he is an integral part of the Receivers actions and is still in control of TM.
scumvilles latest rant very cunningly avoids giving truthful information to his affiliates.
when the SEC shut down TM, scoville said he had been transferring funds from the TM account to his personal account, so that he could transfer them to payza and then pay affiliates with a ‘BOOM’ Surprise.
he Never said he had Already transferred millions to payza [EVP international].
now he says:
well, you secreted funds out through payza and didn’t tell your affiliates that you had done so, and you wont share the details with the receiver, so its obvious you stuffed the funds somewhere for yourself scoville, so stop the BS!
scoville also says he bought a house, paid leases, bought cars with his ‘personal earnings’. well, no one is questioning what he did with his personal earnings, but why did he lie to his affiliates that he was homeless and had to be taken in by his family?
according to the receiver’s report scoville is living in his leased flat in utah. in his rant today scoville cunningly avoids addressing this lie.
scoville rants on that he was sharing his earnings with everyone. apparently this ‘largesse’ is something that should be appreciated by everyone.
what scoville avoids addressing is that his affiliates were investing money with him Because he was giving them an ROI.
if he didn’t ‘share’ the money he collected in his ponzi scheme, he would collect no money to begin with!
scoville apparently finds his lies very amusing, because he cant stop going LOL and LOL.
What is your source for this? Arrest without probable cause? Indefinite hold?
Broadly, reasonable suspicion is necessary for law enforcement to make a stop. Probable cause is required to make an arrest or obtain a search or arrest warrant and charging takes place in court after an arrest. (Criminal)
Someone may be stopped arrested and charged criminally and still be considered innocent until proven guilty (the judicial system determines guilt, not law enforcement.)
You seem to be conflating battlefield capture and detentions of Al Qaeda combatants on foreign soil with domestic US law (or maybe you are not, which is why I asked for your source.)
Scoville has not been charged criminally. SEC v TM is a civil action.
aaand sunil patel is back on FB and announcing plans to go to utah to defend scoville’s ponzi scheme:
so, a few Net Winners may indeed risk their ass and go to utah.
they really think the judge is going to be impressed by a handful of ponzi thieves screaming – ‘give us TM! let us steal more money!!’
what about Net Losers? how many Net Losers are going to utah to fight for TM?
The thing about Ponzi funds it you’re not entitled to receive or keep them.
All that stuff Scoville talks about purchasing was derived from financial fraud. None of it was legitimately purchased.
The Receiver pursuing his wife (ex-wife?) is news to me. Surely any assets purchased pre-Traffic Monsoon would be easy to prove.
Unless Scoville’s full of shit (I’m not holding my breath on that one).
Hey that seems quite reasonable to me. (cough cough – let me clear my throat) 🙂
Speaking of Sunil Patel, I received an incredibly vile, profane, and threatening private message from him recently..
I must research if informing facebook of the message might get him banned from facebook–I think that threatening to kill someone might be illegal.
This is hilarious.
Where’d the “$80 million” come from … TM only or was some portion the returns from Charles’ previous fraudulent schemes?
Doesn’t matter as the entirety is, as Oz noted, likely the proceeds of financial fraud.
Still, if the entirety was from TM, Charles seems to have paid himself quite well, about $40 million a year, which seems pretty good to me for a “business” that at the end of the day lost $55 for every $50 adpack purchase, but as TM kept no financial records, as Oz mentioned in a previous post, I guess we’ll never know for sure.
Or at least, not for awhile yet, after which Charles will need to concoct yet another nonsensical story to explain this away.
Still, if TM was doing so well, why would he have to transfer the “$80 million” in the first place? Was this intended to cover off the $61 million or so that PayPal froze and, if so, is there proof that any was used to pay TM members?
I wonder whether Charles is, for whatever reason, seeking to establish that he’s mentally incompetent as his FB posts increasingly point in this direction.
I know the IRS is going to be mighty interested in Charles’ claim that he made $80 Million in two years since his tax returns show nothing even close to that amount.
Keep on talking Charles and digging that hole deeper and deeper.
I notice that Sunil Patel is now promoting “traffic hurricane” on his personal Facebook page. Apparently, he’s going to use his “profits” from it to “raise funds to help TM”.
He says Traffic Hurricane is run off-shore by Ernie Ganz. I notice he has followers who are already signing up for the latest “deal”!
sunil patel is now claiming he has been invited to be a TEDx speaker on the 5th of nov, 2016:
1] patel does not mention who has invited him to be a TEDx speaker [is it sidra shaukat?].
2] TED and TEDx are different platforms. TED is a global platform which has had speakers like Richard Branson, Bill Gates, Tony robbins etc. TEDx is a locally hosted event which anyone can hold on getting a free TEDx license and following certain principles.
3] why is patel saying being a TEDx speaker is ‘Something i have always wanted to do’?
because, on april 20, 2015 a video was uploaded on youtube by a sidra shaukat saying:
sunil patel and sidra shaukat together run ‘london achievers’ which holds various seminars on property investing, book writing etc.
this video had all of 84 views.
so sidra shaukat organises a local TEDx event and gets her partner sunil patel to speak? are these really TEDx events or are patel and shaukat faking it?
is this TEDx event being organised on nov 5 by shaukat to allow patel an ‘excuse’ to not go down to utah for the hearing on nov 1st?
I thought the same thing when I saw the post.
Far too convenient. That and the blatant attempt to cash in on the TED name is pretty low (it goes without saying TED don’t have dodgy landlords masquerading as Ponzi pimps as speakers).
Patrick Pretty has an article up covering two new Traffic Monsoon lawsuits, filed by investors.
patrickpretty.com/2016/09/20/2-new-lawsuits-filed-against-traffic-monsoon/
I’m about to go through them now so I’ll have something up in a few hours.
there is only one TEDx event in the UK on the 5th of nov, at the kingston university. obviously sunil patel, ponzi speaker, is not on the list of speakers.
this the same sunil patel who claimed that the US SEC called him ‘personally’ before his revolution day party!
this is the same sunil patel who claimed that mark zuckerberg emailed him ‘personally’ to discuss his FB account!
now he’s claiming to be a first time speaker at a TEDx event, while a video last year also introduced him as a TED speaker!
lets have the details sunil patel! where is this TEDx event being organised and by whom? who are the speakers?
i’m pretty sure sunil patel is lying again. he’s a pathological liar and a very stupid liar at that, because his claims are unbelievable to start with!
aw, sunil patel is busting his arteries because we ‘haters’ are questioning his invitation to be a TEDx speaker on nov 5th. 2016.
instead of stomping around on FB in a rage, patel can easily shut up haters by sharing some info about this TEDx event. where is it to be held, who is the organizer and who are the speakers?
TEDx events are usually carefully planned and listed in advance, so patel being ‘invited’ to speak at a tedx event barely a month before it is to be held is very ‘iffy’.
if he is a ‘confirmed speaker’ as he says he is, he should just post proof of such ‘confirmation’, instead of demanding that everyone should just ‘believe’ him. he seems to be a bit deluded and keeps making unbelievable claims, so he must excuse our skepticism.
since he fancies himself as a ‘leader’ with ‘integrity’ fighting for TM, he should not keep making claims and statements he cant back up or stand behind. it makes him look like a complete idiot.
aaand as expected sunil patel has announced he will not be going to utah as there is nothing for him to do there and he wont be allowed into the court room:
i1.wp.com/wheretofindwealth.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/10/screenshot.90.jpg?w=450
it’s strange he thinks he wont be allowed into the court room as scoville’s mother shirley scoville has posted:
there’s no need for patel to make excuses, we’ve always known he wouldn’t be going to utah. he has a criminal conviction in the UK which would make a VISA difficult and he’s just chicken too.
since announcing his TED talk event, patel has not shared any further information about it.
i guess he realized he had invented too big a lie for anyone to believe and using it as an excuse to avoid utah wouldn’t fly.
so, he fell back on posting secret messages in secret groups announcing he’s not going and confirming that he’s a pathological liar.
Come on now, be fair.
Sunil has totally been showing the SEC who’s boss with all those emo Facebook memes.
He’s probably counting on them cancelling the hearing and dropping the case.