Star bonuses cement Javita’s recruitment focus
Ever since I first looked at Javita back in May, I’ve been actively following the company with a particular interest in how Javita choose to market themselves.
With a product as readily retailable as instant coffee sachets, I believed there was no excuse for Javita to go down the recruitment path. If the Javita product was strong enough, business success would naturally take care of itself and in the long term foster organic growth on the basis of demand.
Looking back at how Javita have chosen to market themselves however, and the incentives and training they have offered their members through their marketing arm, Javanomics – I think it’s pretty clear now that a focus on their coffee product and retail sales has well and truly taken a backdoor to focusing on recruitment incentives.
Initially Javita was off to a great start and, despite it being a major drawback due to financial investment for their members, they were promoting their coffee via sampling.
If the coffee was good, this would naturally lead on to sales and build a strong customer base. That should have been where the focus remained.
For whatever reason though (the product?), this seemed to not be working out and Javita then switched to autoship and recruitment incentives.
First we had the dubious marketing campaign asking the question ‘how would you like to add $16,000 per month to your income by finding one person per month by sharing coffee?’
I say dubious because, despite claiming to offer a $16,000 a month income by sharing coffee, the reality is you had to share the Javita business opportunity and ensure that each and every member you recruited (and everyone they recruited and so on and so forth), all brought in one new member and put them on autoship each month for twelve months.
Gone was the product sampling and ‘great tasting coffee’ focus, now it was just straight out recruitment.
Continuing this theme, last month Javita, through Javanomics, launched two marketing incentives for its members.
The first was a cash incentive awarded to the top 3 enrollers of the company each week.
The second was a draw prize of an IPod Nano to members. To get a ticket to the draw, members had to enrol a new member into Javita (entries were capped at one per existing member to keep things fair).
Despite the first competition ultimately judging the winner based on total business volume, the idea is clearly to get as many people on board and stick them on autoship and hope for the best.
The second… well, rewarding people with prizes for recruiting pretty much speaks for itself.
Keep in mind on their own there’s nothing intrinsically wrong with the above promotions, it’s just that they mark a stark departure from Javita’a prelaunch and immediate post launch marketing campaigns that focused on the product.
Moving into September, with the announcement of up and coming Star and Car Bonuses, it seems this initial message and focus on the retail side of things is all but lost.
The Star Bonus
To qualify for the Star Bonus, Javita members must first qualify as a ‘Star’. Members wishing to become ‘stars’ have two options open to them;
The Star Elite Rank
The Star Elite rank is achieved where upon a new member to Javita joins the company with the ‘qualified business pack’ ($599) and within thirty days recruits two new members to Javita who also purchase the $599 pack.
Star Elite members are entitled to receive the Star Bonus, Car Bonus and receive ‘a waiver of the hold time for the Rank Advancement Bonuses at Consultant II and III‘.
The Star Bonus
Once members have qualified for the rank of Star Elite, they are then eligible to receive what is called the ‘Star Bonus’.
The Star Bonus is sort of like a mini 1×2 cycling matrix that pays members out each time it is filled.
The basic idea is that as a Javita member, you have two matrix positions under you. When you enrol someone into Javita and they purchase the $599 joining pack, you fill one of these two matrix positions.
If you fill both positions under you within a 30 day period, you ‘cycle’ and get paid.
The cycle payouts are as follows;
- 1st cycle = $50
- 2nd cycle = $100
- 3rd cycle = $15
- 4th cycle = $200
- every cycle after the 4th = $200
The Star Rank
To qualify at the Star level (this will apply to existing members who have been with Javita for longer than 30 days or who fail to meet the Star Elite requirements), members must recruit two new members to Javita who join with the $599 pack.
Unlike with the Star Elite rank, there is no time limit on this criteria however Star members are only eligible to participate in the Car Bonus program.
The Car Bonus
Details are a bit sketchy at this point but the Javita Car Bonus appears to be your standard Car Bonus offering.
In a nutshell, as you advance your rank in the Javita Compensation Plan, you’re awarded an increasing payment on a new or used car lease.
Usually there’s specific requirements on the age and condition of the car and some companies even limit the color, make and model of the car too.
Oh and if you quit or drop down in membership rank the car lease payments are entirely your problem, not the company’s.
Update 5th September, 2011 – The car bonus is only available to US members of Javita and only American made cars (they haven’t specified which models yet) are covered. /end update
For those who don’t want a car payment or for members who live outside of the US, a ‘cash bonus’ option is available. The cash bonus option pays out 50% of the car bonus and is bundled with member’s monthly commissions.
The car bonus payouts are as follows;
- Supervisor II and III – $300 (only available to Star Elite members)
- Manager – $400
- Director – $600
- Partner – $800
- Chairman – $1000
Conclusion
First and foremost, one would hope there is some way for existing Javita members to achieve the Star Elite rank, otherwise this appears to be a giant slap in the face to the existing Javita memberbase.
As it stands now, the Star Elite and Star Bonus appear to be open only to new members and exists for the sole purpose of encouraging them to go out and recruit new members to Javita.
Unlike the past promotions and incentives, the Star Bonus departs completely from a business volume requirement and solely focuses on recruiting new members to Javita.
This tells me two things;
Either Javita is not selling at all as a retail product, the company is failing as a MLM opportunity and is in desperate need of new members to bring in revenue, or both.
Whatever the case, it’s sad to watch a company start off with a strong product and retail focus deteriorate into a mere numbers game. Whoever is in charge of Javita’s marketing arm clearly have an agenda and that’s to get their existing members to recruit as many new members as possible.
As I said earlier, not a negative goal to have in itself, but when it’s your only growth and success strategy, consistently month after month, then alarm bells start ringing.
As far as I know a launch date hasn’t been set for Javita’s Car and Star Bonuses, but I imagine they’ll be implemented sometime in September.
Will Javita continue their trend and ramp up their recruitment efforts even more in October?
I guess we’ll have to wait and see.
What’s really interesting is… Javita’s business model may in fact be already illegal.
According to this Amway critic site, US Federal Courts have previously ruled that “self-consumption” can NOT be used to satisfy the “70% sales to ultimate user” requirement (part of “Amway Exemption”)
http://www.amquix.info/quixtar_pyramid-q-a.html#buyersclub
Thus, asking people to join and then sign up for autoship may just land Javita in “pyramid scheme” classification.
This is confirmed by Grimes and Reese, MLM Lawyers (who was at one time rumored to be hired by TVI Express, but NEVER confirmed)
http://www.mlmlaw.com/saleswatch/omnitrition.html
I don’t think it’s the model itself (compensation) plan that’s illegal, but definitely how they are promoting the company might be.
There’s clearly provisions within the compensation plan for retail sales, but looking at how Javita are marketing themselves and the incentives they’re throwing at their memberbase, yeah… we very well may have a problem here if someone looked at the books.
The model itself is illegal, Oz. G&R wrote VERY clearly, that compensation can ONLY be paid upon sales. Star bonus is very clearly a recruitment based bonus, not sales based.
“If a program compensates participants, directly or indirectly, merely for the introduction or enrollment of other participants into the program, it is a pyramid.”
–http://www.mlmlaw.com/library/guides/Primer.htm Grimes and Reese website
Wouldn’t ‘program’ be relating to the opportunity as a whole though, rather than a specific bonus?
In that sense the Javita compensation plan does have provisions for retail sales commissions. Obviously these new bonuses don’t but they make up part of the greater compensation plan, or ‘program’.
At least that’s how I’d interpret it (I could very well be wrong).
@Oz — you can’t be “sort of” pyramid scheme. If ONE PART (out of many) comp package is considered to be pyramid scheme, then the business IS a pyramid scheme, in the US that is.
I wonder if whoever came up with this bonus plan ran it by a MLM lawyer or not. I have a feeling they didn’t. The ORIGINAL Javita plan appears to be legal. This new bonus plan just pushed it into the illegal category.
@Oz — upon re-reading your original comp plan review…
Commission payout — appears to be legal, based on sales
Fast Start Bonus — illegal, based on recruitment
Unilevel — appears to be legal, based on sales
RAM bonus — unknown, depends on how the promotion between ranks work. If promo is based on sales, legal. If based on number of downlines (i.e. recruiting), illegal
Manager bonus and other bonuses — appears to be legal, based on sales, but again, depends on how they got to those ranks
That “Fast Start Bonus” is going to sink the whole ship, so to speak.
Just added an update regarding the car bonus payments and also thought I’d add that worringly, Javita are referring to the Star Bonus as
A 100% recruitment driven bonus is now the foundation of Javita?!Ruh-oh….
I signed up with Javita as a member dealer. The product it self is very good… and the concept of putting these herbs in common drinks is genius if you ask me.
I think the compensation plan that the company offers is to increase sales at an exponential rate.
Face it marketing a sachet of coffee that will give you the promise of weight loss, will take a lot of convincing if you do traditional advertising.
The requirement for you to avail the compensation is to increase your sales volume. Its easier and faster if you follow the Star program.
If you enroll just 3 people with a $499 package your sales volume is enough to get rebates and bonuses. If your really good you can have your ROI in just 1 day.
But then what I am fearful for Javita, is that, the compensation plan can be used by some people who are greedy and turn it into a pyramid scam, Focus on recruits and not the product.
I hope my company, the Javita company has safety nets to secure their product. But for me, Networking, direct selling is the best way to promote the JAVITA health drinks.
you have yourself described javita as a product based pyramid scheme. this is what you said:
what this means is:
1] recruitment
2] inventory front loading, of an amount, much larger than which can account for self consumption
3] buying and selling packages for earning bonuses/rebates, ie pyramid scheme
4] ROI!! if you even consider product packages in javita to be investments, it’s a clear sign of what the essence of the business is, ie pyramid scheme.
really fiel, ROI!, that was a freudian slip !
Recruits turn out to be distributors of the product. So, it depends on the individualL who enrolled as a member as to which path he chooses, whether to. acquire more distrutors or sell it retail.
Even if you sell it retail, and not “recruit” in just one day you can get your investment back thats what i meant by ROI. With the 499 pack.
Anjal,
The reason Why i say that the Javita cofffee is Not a pyramid scam is that, consumers who would like to just buy a box of coffee or tea , do not have to sign up to for a membership to get it at a discounted rate, They can just go online, and order it on autoship. ( which you can cancel anytime you want.)
Usually for pyramid scams, consumers are forced to buy a certain product at discounted rate by signing up as a member and you end up with more of what you wanted to buy.
I choose to retail the product because the product sells it self.
Javita, took the MLM / networking plan to promote or advertise the product because it is more cost effective than hiring an AD agency. And you can just imagine, how much that will cost if you go world wide.
Javita coffee is a good product…and as a dealer, i get compensated by the volume of sales I make, i also get compensated if i hire more distributors (recruit).
Either way the company does allow its consumers to purchase a single box at a discounted rate with out signing up as a member. With all these put into consideration, I can not say it is a scam.