BehindMLM turns 5: State of the Industry Address (2015)
Today marks the day BehindMLM has been covering the MLM industry for five years.
As good a time as any I figured to take a look back at where we’ve come from, what’s happening now and where we’re going.
The MLM Industry
When I started writing at BehindMLM I wasn’t entirely sure where I’d wind up. I was an unknown in the space and pretty much had free rein to cover topic at my leisure.
I still have that freedom, but over the years continued to take on the greater responsibility of covering the industry at large.
The good is typically covered by way of press-release. Companies push them out on the various platform they’ve signed up for and attempt to flood the internet.
I see that as covered ground, and instead try to find a middle-ground (reviews), coupled with behind the scenes news you might not necessarily read elsewhere.
I believe an informed decision trumps all, and you’re only ever going to get that by reading as widely as you possibly can.
As to the industry itself, as BehindMLM’s coverage has expanded, I’ve found myself increasingly dwelling in its underbelly.
Perhaps to the chagrin of those who’d prefer to ignore it, I personally can’t separate the underbelly from the rest of the industry. I wouldn’t be doing justice to the reporting and cataloging of the industry that goes on here.
As evidenced by the hundreds of thousands of people who get scammed each year, ignoring the problem doesn’t work.
So instead I try to shine a flashlight on it, along with readers who help out along the way and my fellow blogs who cover similar topics.
What I’ve noticed over the years is that the life of schemes hatched in the MLM underbelly are noticeably experiencing shorter lifespans.
I don’t take any credit for that, but hopefully the trend of increased regulatory action in the space and general awareness of the public continue.
Trend wise I also see Asia emerging as a problematic area going forward. Regulation in the US has tightened up significantly over the last few years.
If your scam takes off in the US, it’s pretty much guaranteed to be shutdown at some point.
What I’m seeing now though is banking based out of Asia (Hong Kong), with principals running schemes from the US. Except for a few isolated cases, the US is still very much where the money is so this will continue to be of interest to track going forward.
I’m expecting we’ll see increased US regulatory co-operation in Asian jurisdictions over the coming years. That might be public cooperation or quietly on the backend.
As to the more legitimate side of the industry, I’m well aware I need to do more to cover it. This primarily going to be by way of reviews, as I don’t think “top leader joins company X” or “company X makes $yy in profit!” type articles offer any real value to readers.
That’s a more marketing orientated style of content, which I’m not interested in pursuing.
Currently I’m at a crossroads time wise, with keeping up with the MLM underbelly taking up most of my time. I maintain an established MLM company list, which I plan to get around to reviewing over time.
If you’ve requested an MLM company review and am wondering why it’s taking so long, that’s why: It’s sitting on my established company review list.
Late last year I sat down and began to plan out how to tackle the problem. This resulted in a roadmap for me to implement throughout 2015.
From a reader standpoint, you should be seeing a lot more established company information appearing on BehindMLM by the end of the year.
And that’s not going to come at the expense of covering the MLM underbelly, with my hope being that I can cover both as diligently as possible.
For most of last year I ignored the matrix-side of the MLM underbelly. I covered a few schemes but between news and other reviews had more than enough content to keep me busy.
The regulatory shutdown of the Achieve Community earlier this year however made me reconsider that approach. This is why you’ve seen vastly increased coverage of MLM cycler activity on here.
I’m almost up to date in that arena, which will then free up some time to cover elsewhere in the industry.
The Blog
Last year I took a week off and put together much of the code powering BehindMLM from scratch.
The old template worked but was bloated and design-wise wasn’t exactly what I wanted.
The end-result is what you see now, which is still somewhat of a work in progress.
There’s little things I want to implement design wise (emphasizing the search box, touching up the sidebar menu graphics, html-friendly email notifications etc.), but overall I think we’re in pretty good shape.
I sometimes get feedback from the odd reader lamenting the “dated” look of the site.
My answer is that’s by design. I know modern blogging trends call for big splashy graphics, sliders and sidebars where you have to click around to get the information you want: but I’m a fan of any of that.
BehindMLM’s value lies in its information, so anything that pushes that from the forefront of your focus is unnecessary clutter in my eyes.
The way the site is built is to present you as easily as possible with what you’re after. The sidebar shows you what’s happening at a glance, with the recent comments letting you jump into what’s currently being discussed on the site.
It’s the kind of site I’d like to read, and that seems to have served us well over the years.
On the topic of mobile, there’s a Google update coming out later this month that is tipped to shake up mobile search listings.
More than anything, this seems to be a push to punish sites that aren’t responsive. At least that’s how I’m reading it.
BehindMLM isn’t responsive.
Back last year when I was redesigning we were for a bit, but readers on mobile devices complained the responsive design got rid of the sidebar.
The feedback section was the part most missed, so with that in mind I disabled the responsive design altogether.
If I go back over the last six months so of our analytics data, mobile makes up just shy of 30% of the traffic to BehindMLM.
That said I don’t think we’re going to be negatively impacted by the upcoming update, because BehindMLM is pretty readable on mobile.
At least when I’ve randomly looked at it has been. I don’t really use mobile devices for the internet (anything less than a desktop/laptop just annoys me), so this isn’t something I can comment too much on.
Any feedback from mobile users would be appreciated. But otherwise I think I’ll just adopt a wait and see approach and see what happens after this update hits.
The Future
After five years, I’m pretty happy with where BehindMLM is at right now.
The demand for unbiased third-party information on the MLM industry is as strong as ever, and I plan to continue meeting it to the best of my ability.
I don’t know what’s going on over at Alexa, but February and March 2015 were two of our busiest months on record (4th and 5th respectively).
Where do I want the site to go in the future?
I’ve always wanted BehindMLM to be a definite information resource for all things MLM. That’s been the idea right from the beginning.
To that end we’re slowly getting there. I’m fast closing in on two thousand articles and I think if I’ve learnt anything over the past five years, it’s that I’m never going to run out of content to cover.
There’s still so much to industry that doesn’t get reported, despite me and my fellow MLM bloggers doing our best.
My vision for the site is to be the ultimate due diligence database for the industry. Combine that with reader comments and insight, and you’ve really got no better place to get a snapshot of what’s happening.
Once I’ve freed up a bit more time towards the end of this year and I’ve got time to explore topics in more detail, I’m looking forward to expanding our coverage into the more theoretical arena too. This includes opinion pieces and more exploratory articles.
Right now I’m sort of in a news/review lockdown, which can get a bit stale.
Especially when news has been rather quiet this last month or so! 2015 in that respect hasn’t been anywhere near as busy as 2014 in that respect.
On the flipside though, there’s currently not one blatantly obvious scam operating out of the US that I can point to and say: “That’s the one regulators need to go after right now.”
You’ve got a smattering of smalltime crooks stirring the pot, but nothing has really emerged as a major player.
Longer-term stories like Herbalife will continue to play out, but as far the MLM underbelly goes – things have been pretty quiet since Achieve Community was shut down.
As readers of BehindMLM I hope you’re enjoying and/or have enjoyed the journey thus far. I’m always open to suggestions and feedback, which is best delivered via the contact form.
Otherwise, thanks for the support over the years and continued belief in what is I do here. Not just for reading but also for the countless hours you put into additional research, news tips and helping to contribute to the running of the site.
More eyes on the industry is always going to catch more than my two alone, and I really do think we’ve got one of the largest global audiences keeping watch on the MLM industry here.
For that I’m grateful and no words can adequately express how truly appreciative I am.
Here’s to another 5 years and beyond…
well said well said, and happy birthday to behindmlm.
1] i like that you intend to cover ‘established MLM companies’.
2] i like that you wont fidget with the current simple and user friendly design.
3] i like that you intend to introduce articles about the ‘theory’ behind MLM, and opinion pieces [you could invite industry leaders and lawyers to share their views! just super!]
4] how about introducing some simple method of ‘block quoting’, most non computer experts cant figure that out? that will save you time as a moderator.
here’s to the next five, and oz should be paying for a round of drinks!
Cheers to you, Oz — for the first five years, and many years beyond.
PPBlog
@anjali Thanks for the feedback.
This is difficult because I’m often at odds with the regulars. I think part of the problem is that alot of the service providers in the industry have marketing caps on, whereas I’m just publishing raw information.
Meshing the two together is difficult.
I think it’s not something I’ll actively pursue, but perhaps if the need arises let it happen organically. I tend to follow common-sense, which goes for other people’s opinions to. Deferring based on a professional title doesn’t sit comfortably with me (Gerry Nehra!).
M_Norway suggested a FAQ I think over two years ago. And it’s been sitting on my todo list ever since! I’m literally struggling to set aside time to work on the site itself.
Pretty much over the past two to three years there hasn’t been a day I’ve woken up and gone “right, not much to write about today, let’s work on the site!”. And that’s writing 6-7 days a week continuously, with the exception of my blog breaks (usually once annually).
I haven’t touched the comments system since the redesign last year, during which I only really changed the formatting of the comments and cleaned them up.
In the meantime, for block quotes just wrap what you want to quote with brackets (the triangle one not square). You can quote a comment using the ‘(Q)’ button and then edit as you wish, with a preview down the bottom showing you in real time how your edits look.
I don’t mind moderation time, I see it as part of site maintenance. Readability is extremely important to me as is conversation flow, so I try to focus on those.
Email response time though is something I definitely need to work on. Again, I’m implementing some changes in my life throughout the second half of the year that I hope will address these issues going forward (mostly I just need to free up time).
Oz with your endless support of keeping us informed a many thank you.
Also patrick pretty and Lynndale and the many readers who take time from their day to report to this blog and Patrick’s.
Along with real scam makes this a very powerful tool to help cut into the scammers like Dr Lier van naste and julie higgins along with all the new scammers that keep trying to steal our money. My hats off to all you guys.
Cheers Oz!
I must say reading your blog was always a pleasure. In fact, it was here I’ve learned about MLM, or better, MLM scams, when I used to think Herbalife was all alone in the world… LOL.
Happy 5th anniversary, Oz!
Thank you for your well detailed, informative, and entertaining reports on the good and the bad of the mlm industry. May this blog be around for many more years.
Although, there may be those who despise this site, there are many more who appreciate the “Heads up” on the ponzis, the scams, the schemes, the schemers and the scammers who every day prey on the innocent, the ignorant, and the gullible.
There are many who avoided getting taken for the money grab ride so prevalent today, and learned how to spot the deceivers.
Yours has been a much needed service.
Congrats and cheers!
OZ:
Congratulations on your 5th year anniversary, and looking forward to many, many, many more to come. When it comes to MLM, you are the first site we recommend people to read about MLM programs.
Continued success and thanks for all you do to help educate, warn, and prevent people from becoming a victim of these unscrupulous MLM Programs.
aw, don’t be a hardass. a few opinions never hurt, after all they are from the same industry that you cover.
there are voices which share your views, and voices that don’t, and if both can state their views from time to time, it will make your blog ‘interesting’, without disturbing your regular coverage of various companies.
just imagine! you can roundly scold off people you disagree with, never mind their ‘professional titles’ 🙂
i’d suggest at least trying it, to see if it works and adds value.
for example you could invite views about the ‘pros and cons of the amway model’, ‘how to deal with ponzi schemes’, ‘advice to the MLM industry’,’what not to do in MLM’ etc etc. it doesn’t have to be too adversarial, if the topic is right.
hey! i learned how to blockquote. thanks!!
Congratulations on 5 years! It is amazing at how quickly things are moving. I wish you the very best in your on going success in reporting on this industry.
Well done on five successful years. May you have many more.
Happy Birthday, Oz! Keep us informed of any new scams. We need to be well aware of who is trying to trick us. Hats off to you!
Oz,
Often we do not agree, however many of your reviews are spot on 🙂
Aw bring it in, group hug!
Happy 5th anniversary.
Happy 5th Anniversary, I really enjoy reading your posts Oz! Keep up the good work! Cheers!
Awesome! Great work man.
You probably mean a WYSIWYG type of editor for the comments, “What You See Is What You Get”?
They usually have too many functions, but they will allow users to click on buttons instead of entering the HTML-tags manually.
Great writing, You deserve the widest possible audience and I hope you get it.
Congrats
I’d like to add an Honorable Mention to all the contributors to this blog who also play an important role in keeping everyone informed with your edifying comments.
We get further insight to the reported stories, helping us folk make better informed decisions.
Thank you all as well.
wow 5 years already.
Its amazing how many reviews OZ has done over the years that are really spot on correct.
Yet people refuse to see the truth of what is in plain open sight here.
If you continue with this for another 5 and beyond I am sure many will LOOK HERE before they leap!
Excellent work here OZ!
@ted nuyten
i just checked your businessforhome.org, where you have listed top earners in the MLM industry, and include tony rush of dubli, on this list.
this isn’t the correct thread to ask you this, so apologies to readers, but unfortunately ted nuyten is ‘here’, so i have to ask him ‘here’.
dubli is a strongly debated company on behindmlm, and the common conclusion is that it is a pyramid, because the third party product ‘shopping’ does not generate enough revenue, and the recruiting matrix is where the money is, and comes from.
secondly tony rush is part of team WUKAR,dubli, which is a training and lead selling illegal business, functioning as a subset of dubli.
could you add your views on this thread?
https://behindmlm.com/companies/dubli-network/dubli-review-recruitment-and-e-commerce/
shock and surprise!!
c’mon passive readers. this guy oz, has been working free of charge night&day, to protect your asses.
this is a ‘five year anniversary’ with almost 2000 articles By One Person!
Show some Love!!! it’s freefreefree.
Time surely flies by…. Happy 5th anniversary!!!
Congrats on 5 Years Oz!
Great work exposing all the scams and scammers!
Congratulations on five great years, Oz. I think you’ve made a very significant and valuable impact.
I wholeheartedly agree. The way the major mainstream news providers force me to accept auto-loading videos I have no interest in seeing has me looking elsewhere.
Absolutely. The cooperation, appreciation and support between the scrutinizers of these online opportunities and SCAMS compounds ultimate effectiveness for everyone.
SD
Hi Oz
Many thanks for all your articles over the last five years. ‘Ive been paying close attention to your site all this time and find it a valuable and useful tool that gives no nonsense , straight to the point info on the underbelly of the MLM world.
BTW don’t change the layout of your site. Its perfectly fine as it is.
Here’s to another 5 more years.
Happy Birthday behindmlm, I agree that your rev share, Ponzi analysis is almost always spot on. Great job!
Would you agree that MAPS is a blatantly obvious USA based PONZI that requires regulatory action ASAP? One coin if it was USA based.
Here’s to 5 more great years OZ!
best blog ever!
@PD (and others)
Thanks for the support. I’ve already penned my thoughts on MAPS and OneCoin n separate reviews.
OZ, Why not enable Jetpack Mobile Theme?
This will help with the responsive issue… It’s not the prettiest way but can be modified to some degree.
And even if it’s more simple looking that’s ok… we come to read the content, not look at fancy sliders etc.
Here’s to 5 more years!
Congratulations, Oz !!!!
@Erik
Thanks for the suggestion.
I’m a bit wary of an automated theme plugin, as it’s inevitably going to introduce bloat and likely break functionality.
My thinking is if you want to do mobile then you need to design it from the ground up. A bandaid plugin is probably going to be worse than leaving it as is :).
Yes… If you want it done right, do it yourself!