Pink Zebra Review: Sprinkle fragrances
Pink Zebra launched in 2011. The company is based out of Texas and operates in the fragrances MLM niche.
Heading up Pink Zebra are co-founders Tom and Kelly Gaines.
As per a 2016 Direct Selling News interview;
Back in 1997, well before launching Pink Zebra, the Gaineses had tested the Sprinkles product through Bath & Body Works.
“If it was going to be successful anywhere, it would be successful there,” Tom says. The store’s approach is very hands-on and service-oriented, providing an opportunity for staff to engage with customers and to have the opportunity to tell them about the products.
The product was distributed in 30 stores and, says Tom, “it was a complete failure.”
Tom, Kelly and the buyers thought the product was great. The consumers, though, he says, “didn’t really understand it—it really needed demonstration.” It needed the direct sales approach that would allow for that personal touch.
Prior to going at it alone the Gainses worked in a candle factory, which is where they met.
There’s a large unexplained gap between the 1997 Bath & Body Works attempt and Pink Zebra’s 2011 launch. I wasn’t able to establish whether the Gaineses were involved in other MLM companies during that time.
Read on for a full review of Pink Zebra’s MLM opportunity.
Pink Zebra’s Products
Pink Zebra’s flagship product is their Sprinkles line.
Sprinkles are small individual wax melts, which Pink Zebra states are ‘made with our Soft Soy wax, fragrance blends and dyes.
I counted fifty-seven individual Sprinkles fragrances in 3.75 oz. jars at $9 each.
The Sprinkles carton variety retails at $28 for a 16 oz. container.
I noted the carton variety came up one fragrance short, which I’m putting down to supply issues.
To compliment purchased Sprinkles Pink Zebra sells a range of
- “simmering lights” for $39 each
- “accent shades” to house simmering lights for $25 to $65 and
- “simmer pots” for $28 to $35
Liquid fragrances are available as “soaks” (incl accessories), as well as a “wallhug” diffuser.
While fragrances are definitely Pink Zebra’s flagship lines, the company also markets a range of hand soap and sanitizer under “Supa Clean”.
A full catalog of products with retail pricing is available from Pink Zebra’s website.
Pink Zebra’s Compensation Plan
Pink Zebra’s compensation plan pays commissions on generated sales volume through a unilevel team.
The unilevel is expanded via a generational bonus. Additional performance-based bonuses are also on offer.
Pink Zebra Affiliate Ranks
There are eight affiliate ranks within Pink Zebra’s compensation plan.
Along with their respective initial qualification criteria, they are as follows:
- Consultant – sign up as a Pink Zebra affiliate and generate and maintain $400 PV a month
- Executive Consultant – maintain $400 PV a month and recruit and maintain three personally recruited Consultants
- Manager – maintain $400 PV a month and recruit and maintain four affiliates (two of which must be Executive Consultants)
- Senior Manager – maintain $400 PV a month, generate and maintain $15,000 GV a month and maintain four personally recruited affiliates (two of which must be Managers)
- Executive Manger – maintain $400 PV, generate and maintain $30,000 GV a month and maintain four personally recruited affiliates (two of which must be Senior Managers)
- Director – maintain $400 PV a month, generate and maintain $50,000 GV a month and recruit and maintain five affiliates (four Managers and one Executive Manager)
- Executive Director – maintain $400 PV a month, generate and maintain $100,000 GV a month and recruit and maintain six affiliates (four Managers, One Executive Manager and one Director)
- Presidential Director – maintain $400 PV a month, generate and maintain $150,000 GV a month and maintain four personally recruited affiliates (Director or higher)
Once qualified for, monthly rank maintenance qualification criteria is as follows:
- Consultant – maintain $400 PV a month
- Executive Consultant – maintain $400 PV a month and maintain three personally recruited Consultants
- Manager – maintain $400 PV and $5000 GV a month and maintain four personally recruited affiliates (two Executive Consultants or higher)
- Senior Manager – maintain $400 PV and $10,000 GV a month and maintain four personally recruited affiliates (two Executive Consultants or higher)
- Executive Manager – maintain $400 PV and $15,000 GV a month and maintain four personally recruited affiliates (two Executive Consultants or higher)
- Director – maintain $400 PV and $25,000 GV a month and maintain four personally recruited affiliates (two Executive Consultants or higher)
- Executive Director – maintain $400 PV and $100,000 GV a month and maintain four personally recruited affiliates (two Executive Consultants or higher)
- Presidential Director – maintain $400 PV and $150,000 GV a month and maintain four personally recruited affiliates (two Executive Consultants or higher)
PV stands for “Personal Volume” and is sales volume generated by retail sales and an affiliates own orders.
Pink Zebra’s compensation plan states that
commissionable volume is 75% value of Sales Volume (SV is calculated at 92% of catalog/retail price).
GV stands for “Group Volume” and is PV generated by an affiliate and their downline.
At Manager, no more than 60% of required GV can be counted from any one unilevel team leg.
At Senior Manager and higher, no more than 40% of required GV can be counted from any one unilevel team leg.
Note that only commission qualified affiliates count towards rank recruitment criteria.
Stated ranks in the recruitment qualification criteria above are minimum ranks required.
Commission Qualification
To qualify for commissions, a Pink Zebra affiliate must generate and maintain $400 PV a month.
Retail Commissions
Pink Zebra affiliates earn a base 25% commission on retail sales and recruited affiliate orders.
The base retail commission can be increased meeting monthly sales volume targets:
- generate $900 to $1999 in monthly sales volume and receive a 30% commission rate
- generate $2000+ in monthly sales volume and receive a 35% commission rate
Note that sales volume targets include an affiliate’s own purchases.
Residual Commissions
Pink Zebra pays residual commissions via a unilevel compensation structure.
A unilevel compensation structure places an affiliate at the top of a unilevel team, with every personally recruited affiliate placed directly under them (level 1):
If any level 1 affiliates recruit new affiliates, they are placed on level 2 of the original affiliate’s unilevel team.
If any level 2 affiliates recruit new affiliates, they are placed on level 3 and so on and so forth down a theoretical infinite number of levels.
Pink Zebra caps payable unilevel levels at four. Residual commissions are paid at 3% of sales volume generated across these four levels.
- Consultants earn 3% on level 1
- Executive Consultants earn 3% on levels 1 and 2
- Managers earn 3% on levels 1 to 3
- Senior Managers and higher earn 3% on levels 1 to 4
Note that from the Executive Consultant rank, Pink Zebra affiliates are able to place personally recruited affiliates in their unilevel team (as opposed to automatically being placed on level 1).
Any placed affiliates do not count towards rank qualification as they are not new unilevel legs.
Generation Bonus
The Generation Bonus begins at Director and is paid on up to three generations per unilevel team leg.
Pink Zebra define a generation when a Director or higher ranked affiliate is found in a unilevel team leg.
This ranked affiliate caps off the first generation for the leg, with the second beginning immediately after.
If no second Director or higher ranked affiliate is found in the leg, the second generation extends down the full depth of the leg.
If a second Director exists deeper in the leg, they cap off the second generation. The third generation begins directly under them.
Using this generational structure, Pink Zebra affiliates are able to earn on sales volume generated across three generations per unilevel team leg.
- Directors earn 3% on up to one generation per unilevel team leg
- Executive Directors earn 3% on the first generation and 2% on the second
- Presidential Directors earn 3% on the first generation and 2% on the second and third
Quick Start Incentive
The Quick Start Incentive is referenced in Pink Zebra’s compensation plan as follows:
Quick Start is an incentive that is available to any new Consultant for the first 90 days and awards Pink Dollars for achieving sales and sponsoring milestones.
The incentive also rewards Consultants when they achieve the leadership level of Manager.
Reports are run once per month and rewarded consistent with the commission period of the 10th of the month.
Quick Start is an annual incentive and is may be changed at the beginning of each year.
Refer to the current Quick Start incentive flier for all details.
A 2017 flier reveals the Quick Start Incentive is paid in “Pink Dollars”, which are used to purchase Pink Zebra products.
- Level 1 – generate $500 PV within your first thirty days and receive 75 Pink Dollars
- Level 2 – generate $1000 PV between days 31 to 60 and receive 125 Pink Dollars
- Level 3 – generate another $1000 PV between days 61 to 90 and receive 150 Pink Dollars
The Quick Start Incentive also has a downline component, paying 75 Pink Dollars on up to three personally recruited affiliates who qualify for Level 1 within your first ninety days.
While the above information is dated from 2017, I don’t imagine the Quick Start Incentive changes much from year to year.
Sponsoring Bonus
The Sponsoring Bonus is a 7% bonus on sales volume generated by personally recruited affiliates.
Mentoring Bonus
The Mentoring Bonus is paid on sales volume generated down to a specific ranked affiliate in a unilevel team leg.
The first tier of the Mentoring Bonus starts at Executive Manager, and pays 2% on each unilevel team leg down to the first found Executive Manager or higher ranked affiliate in the leg.
If no such ranked affiliate exists, 2% is paid out on sales volume generated down the entire depth of the leg.
The second tier of the Mentoring Bonus applies to Director and higher ranked affiliates.
Directors and higher receive a 3% bonus on downline sales volume, paid down to the first Executive Manager or higher found in a unilevel team leg.
Joining Pink Zebra
Pink Zebra affiliate membership requires the purchase of a Consultant Kit.
- Starter Kits cost $129
- Deluxe Kits cost $199
The difference between the kits is bundled Pink Zebra products.
Conclusion
We have one melt lamp in our house so I’m somewhat familiar with the product niche.
What I’m not clear on is the difference between your traditional “chocolate bar” size melts and Pink Zebra’s sprinkles.
I suppose realistically there’s no much difference, other than being able to fine-tune the amount of wax you’re adding to your melter.
What I will give Pink Zebra credit for is the range of fragrances available. “Old Fashioned Donut” might not be my thing (who wants to feel hungry all the time?), but it’s there if you want it.
Personally I’m more of a sandalwood guy, which I noted isn’t a fragrance Pink Zebra offers.
Sawdust and leather though, they’ve got you covered.
As for pricing Pink Zebra’s products seem reasonable. I punched “16 oz wax melts” into Amazon and didn’t see any big discrepancies.
One thing I will add though is the claim that Pink Zebra’s sprinkle melts don’t work in non-company melters.
Note that Pink Zebra does warn that Sprinkles “do not perform the same in competitors warming systems.
As I own a melter, I can tell you there’s nothing particularly unique about it. There’s a globe that functions as the lamp component, and you place the melts on top.
Heat transfers through the metal bowl top and the wax melts.
For reference Pink Zebra’s lamps use 25 W globes (you can buy replacements in their store).
I went and checked my own melter and found it uses a 25 W globe too. Is there really a difference in using a Pink Zebra product versus my own melter?
I don’t have a problem with Pink Zebra marketing their own melters. Be honest about it though; there’s no need to pretend wax melts differently in a functionally identical melter.
On the off-chance there’s something I’m totally missing here, feel free to let me know in the comments below.
Moving onto compensation, Pink Zebra’s recommended marketing strategy is home parties.
How do I sell Pink Zebra?
Pink Zebra is a party plan company and focuses on providing you tools, incentives, and training to support having great parties for you and your Host.
We recently introduced an industry leading Blend Bash party which makes partying even more fun and successful.
We do support all sales such as in-person, website, and events, in addition to parties.
Given the current climate home parties are not ideal, but one can’t fault Pink Zebra for that.
Outside of the pandemic we’re in, home parties make sense as you really need to smell fragrances to get an appreciation of them.
For example, I might really like “Santa Cruz Sunset”;
Weathered driftwood, salted ocean breeze combined with gentle swirls of bonfire smoke – a perfect summer night.
But on the name and description alone I wouldn’t be confident purchasing without running a smell test first.
One thing to watch out for, and that particularly applies to wax melts is sample costs. You’re obviously going to need samples to run a successful home party, but don’t fall into the trap of letting costs get away from you if the sales aren’t there.
Actual compensation is pretty simple in Pink Zebra, which isn’t a negative.
You’re essentially looking at a four-level deep unilevel, fleshed out with a generational bonus.
I noted there’s no retail volume requirements, which is a concern given the aforementioned hidden costs of hosting marketing parties.
Not helping is Pink Zebra also paying commissions on an affiliate’s own purchases:
If he or she places a Consultant Order or uses the Consultant Pay when placing a party order, the Consultant receives or retains the 25% when he or she places the order.
This means the Consultant receives a 25% commission at the time he or she places the order.
This sounds like a regular wholesale discount but for some reason Pink Zebra have framed it as a commission.
Kinda makes it sound like your earning money when in fact you’re not.
Month to month Pink Zebra affiliates are required to generate $400 in sales volume. I feel this is a bit high, specifically for new affiliates.
That high ceiling could potentially lead to months of marketing spend (see home party concerns above), before a Pink Zebra affiliate gets anywhere near $400 in sales a month.
And god help you if you’re self-qualifying by spending $400 a month in product. Nobody needs that and you’re inventory loading.
What I’d like to see is Pink Zebra address this with retail volume requirements. Wax melts might have a shelf-life but it’s not immediate.
Do away with calling the wholesale discount a commission, and affiliates should only be getting paid when product is sold to retail customers.
Pink Zebra have made some effort with the sliding retail commission rate but I think they can do more.
With respect to rank qualification, I found it odd that rank requirements were lessened once initially qualified for.
I get giving affiliates a safety-net if their volume drops but realistically how is GV going to be maintained with drastically smaller teams (with respect to downline rank requirement)?
Ultimately what you want to see in a potential Pink Zebra upline is them hitting at least $200 in retail sales (half of the PV requirement) each month. If they aren’t hitting that and are trying to sign up you, that’s not a good sign.
One last thing I’ll touch on is this, taken from Pink Zebra’s FAQ:
What happens if I drink my Soaks?
It will taste terrible. DO NOT DRINK Soaks.
There’s a running joke in MLM circles based on people drinking essential oils (sadly based on it actually happening).
I don’t know if Pink Zebra are being overly cautious or addressing people actually drinking their soaks, but if anyone even remotely suggests their products are drinkable – run.
Good luck!
It’s difficult to find much to like about this company. They are selling the same products that failed miserably in the conventional market.
OK, that happened with Tupperware, but that was because Tupperware had a legitimately revolutionary product. Scented wax and heaters is far from revolutionary; the market is pretty much saturated.
[Note: “saturated” is often mis-defined by MLM apologists as meaning there are no buyers left. After that mis-definition, they counter by saying new people are born all the time, so how can there be saturation?
The answer is two-fold: 1) Birth rates are limited by Nature, while recruitment rates are not; 2) That’s not what saturation means. Saturation means the market has plenty of sources for the product, so a new supplier is going to have a tough time of it.]
There are plenty of existing sources for wax heaters and scented waxes, and most customers that want them already have a source.
Then there are the prices, which run 40 to 100% higher than market. On Amazon, a premium heater can be had for $25, and the going rate for scented soy wax runs about $1 per ounce in small quantities.
Against that, a Pink Zebra affiliate would be selling $40 heaters and nearly $2/ounce for wax in bulk. Even with a 25-35% discount, it is not competitive.
The fact that Pink Zebra’s waxes won’t work with competitive heaters? Big problem right there, because most potential customers probably already have their own heater..
Will they want to buy another one just to use Pink Zebra’s waxes? Not likely.
A 25-35% discount is too low a profit margin to meet expenses. In retail, 40-50% is pretty close to breaking even; anything less than that is operating at a loss. Mary Kay offers a 50% discount and almost no Mary Kay rep makes any money.
$400 per month minimum PV is crazy high for a low-cost product like this. Most affiliates will not come close to selling that much.
Anyone with a downline will be sorely tempted to buy stuff they don’t need to meet it so they qualify for commission from their GV. This is how people in MLMs go into debt in a hurry: spending money they can’t afford to “grow” a pretend business.
I am frankly mystified that anyone would willingly sign up for a company that writes their own excuses for not paying out commissions. I’m speaking of the silly 40% and 60% rules. They can only benefit the company at the expense of the affiliate, while putting pressure on the affiliates to push their weak downline legs to order more.
I’m reminded of the BitClub Network founders, where one described the other (in private) as having…
Pink Zebra, if you’re going to pay commission, pay what you owe. Don’t punish people for having too strong a leg in their downline. That’s just wrong.
I visited Pink Zebra’s website to get a feel for the company. Their landing page has a 1:17 video, which I thought was kind of short for describing the company’s product line and commission plan.
Well, it was short because it had zero content. It was just scenes spliced together of sales meetings and retreats, with an annoying soundtrack poured all over it.
The images were far from compelling, with women waving pom-poms and wearing sashes and tiaras…is this a business or a high-school homecoming party?
The only message was “Join Our Team,” with no reasons given for why anyone would want to. And the rest of the site is pretty much the same: join and recruit, but mostly recruit, because that’s where the money is. For Pink Zebra, anyway.
I didn’t price-check the melters. If they’re selling way above competition maybe that’s why “our sprinkles don’t work in other brand’s melters”.
A better question is why not just diffuse essential oil directly, rather than through a wax? (The answer is: so we can make our wax only work on our own heaters)
I can’t speak for Pink Zebra but going with wax over oils was my partner’s decision.
Storage maybe? Although I suppose oil comes in a bottle. I think cost might be a factor. One “chocolate square” melts down and lasts a while.
Essential oil comes in a small bottle (one use?) and costs more than a block of melts.
I still have a hard time believing Pink Zebra’s sprinkles wouldn’t melt just like any other wax on our standard 25w melter.
Since incandescent lightbulbs convert over 95% of the electricity they use directly into heat, their lightbulb-based heaters will produce about 24W of heat (ultimately of course 100% turns into heat, but the bit that escapes as light warms up the room generally, not the heating surface).
It’s an entertaining notion that there could be a difference between the 24W of heat coming from a light bulb sold by Pink Zebra, and a competitor’s 24W. I’m sure the ones with a heating plate, what they call “simmer pots”, use the same amount of power, since they’re meant to melt the exact same wax.
And soy wax is soy wax, theirs doesn’t melt at a different temperature than anyone else’s. Their gimmick is selling it in flakes with perfume and colorant already added, whereas soy wax flakes are usually sold white and unscented as a base material for making candles. The choice of dye and scent being left to the creativity of the candle maker.
If one likes the ideas of the “sprinkles” format, one can of course part-reverse that process and simply chop up a scented candle.
What struck me as weird was the use of incandescent light bulbs. That’s so quaint, I haven’t seen one of those in ages. The EU started banning all incandescent bulbs from 2009 onwards, starting with the ones of 100W and more. 15W and 25W were the last ones to go, they could be sold until 2012. Halogen ones, which produce nearly as much heat, are gone too.
The only incandescent bulbs you can still get in Europe (the few non-EU countries tend to follow suit in these things) are “special purpose” ones, a category which isn’t clearly defined but in practice is mostly the little ones used in fridges and ovens.
Unless they can pass off the ones in their heaters as being “special purpose”, they’re cutting themselves off from the European market in that regard. (I think one could reasonably argue that using them as high-efficienty heating elements should indeed fall under the “special purpose” exemption – the ban exists because using them as light sources is so horribly inefficient.)
Essential oil actually last a lot longer. Most diffusers don’t even use a heating element. They use an ultrasound generator to vibrate the water into “vapor”. You add water to a water reservoir, then just add about 5-8 drops of oil, and that should last several hours.
Large capacity diffusers have larger reservoirs and thus can go longer between fillings. And obviously auto-shutoff for safety reasons. A small bottle (couple mLs) should last weeks depending on how much diffusing is done daily.
Ah, thanks for filling in that blank.
Still prefer our lamp though, it doubles as a dim light that doesn’t distract when watching TV/movies.
Like petroleum paraffin, soy wax can be manufactured with higher melting points.
Paraffin is actually a family of long hydrocarbon-chain molecules. The molecule size can be tweaked in the refinery, and the larger the molecule, the higher the melting point.
Soy wax is different: it’s hydrogenated fat, and its intrinsic melting point is low. However, additives can raise its melting point; it is possible to make soy wax that won’t melt in standard heaters.
By the same token, a 25W heater’s plate temperature can be raised by making it smaller and/or shinier.
A smaller plate means more power per unit area, which will raise the temperature. Shiny metal doesn’t radiate heat away as efficiently as matte-black, so that would get it hotter also.
A thermal break around the plate would keep heat from escaping into the surrounding crockery, etc., etc.
So Pink Zebra could be telling the truth when they say their wax bits won’t melt in an ordinary heater. I’m not saying they are, just that they could be. But truth or fiction, it’s dumb marketing.
Their exclusive wax pellets will only work with their exclusive heater, locking prospective buyers into a single source for heaters and waxes.
Ask Sony how well that sales model worked for them and BetaMax.
Except that we know that their heaters are completely generic, since some of them use a 25W lightbulb as the heat source, and there’s only one kind of 25W.
Their wax must therefore be equally generic, and melt in all heaters with the same design and the same wattage bulb.
One can find tons of these on Alibaba/Aliexpress. The ones with a heating plate must produce the same temperature, since they sell only one kind of wax.
The size and shape and material of the heating element is immaterial, since the wax isn’t heated directly.
The bulb just heats up the air, which heats up the little ceramic bowl, which is about the same size in all these things.
The bowls therefore all reach about the same temperature: the one you get from putting a thin ceramic bowl of roughly 9cm diameter on top of a tubular enclosed air compartment, with about 25W of heat dissipated into it.
You could put a 25W soldering iron in there, which obviously has a much higher temperature at its tip than the surface of the lightbulb, and you’d get the same temperature in the bowl.
You’re right about heat escaping, though, and I should correct one thing I said above: the ones with the heating plate will need a little less power than the lightbulb ones to reach that temperature, since the plate is in contact with the bowl directly, and you don’t have as much heat escaping through the side walls as with the bulb heaters. (They of course also don’t lose the few percents of power which go into producing light.)
But for those who think that an exact temperature is really that critical for warming up different brands of such a simple generic product, there are loads of temperature-adjustable heaters available on AliExpress, for less than the Pink Zebra ones.
I don’t own any heaters or scented wax, nor have I studied many pictures to see how similar or dissimilar the various heater designs are. I’m just a humble engineer who knows it’s theoretically possible to make two heaters that use the same 25W bulb but create different plate temperatures.
The hotter one would have to be smaller in size and melt less wax at a time because physics, but it could be done.
I seriously doubt the veracity of Pink Zebra’s claim that their wax will only work in their heater, because it makes so little sense. Why re-invent the wheel?
It makes even less sense to make that claim if it isn’t true, so I guess Pink Zebra is either dumb or dumber.
[Here’s a fun fact: 25W is how much sunlight hits a standard 158mm-square solar cell in full sun.
A decent cell will convert 22% of that light into 5.5 watts of electrical power, making solar cells much more efficient a turning light into electric power than most incandescent bulbs are at doing the opposite. LED light sources fare better at 30-40%.]
MLM or not, Oz, I hope you are aware that you are trading in your health for a nice smell there.
These products release all sorts of particles and substances into the air and, ultimately, via absorption by your respiratory tract, into your body.
I think I’m doing alright with the waxes. You’re not so much burning anything as heating it up.