Passivo Review: Lending ruse Dubai MLM crypto Ponzi
Passivo (aka Passive Hub), operates in the cryptocurrency MLM niche.
Passivo is known to operate from three primary website domains:
- passivo.com – private registration last updated on February 2nd, 2023
- passivohub.com – privately registered on July 7th, 2023
- passivo.io – private registration last updated July 4th, 2023
Heading up Passivo is CEO Jan Lubberding.
I wasn’t able to put together an MLM history on Lubberding. This is a potential red flag.
A definite red flag is Lubberding appearing to be a German crypto bro hiding out in Dubai:
Instead of acknowledging it’s being run from Dubai, Passivo provides shell company details for Passivo Ltd. on its website.
Passivo Ltd. is purportedly registered in Seychelles, a known tax-haven with no active MLM securities related regulation.
Due to the proliferation of scams and failure to enforce securities fraud regulation, BehindMLM ranks Dubai as the MLM crime capital of the world.
BehindMLM’s guidelines for Dubai are:
- If someone lives in Dubai and approaches you about an MLM opportunity, they’re trying to scam you.
- If an MLM company is based out of or represents it has ties to Dubai, it’s a scam.
If you want to know specifically how this applies to Passivo, read on for a full review.
Passivo’s Products
Passivo has no retailable products or services.
Affiliates are only able to market Passivo affiliate membership itself.
Passivo’s Compensation Plan
Passivo affiliates invest $100 or more on the promise of a a weekly passive ROI.
- invest $100 to $49,999 and receive 0.8% a week
- invest $50,000 or more and receive 1% a week
Note that while Passivo solicits investment in USD and cryptocurrency, withdrawals are only paid in tether (USDT).
For reference: $1 USD = 1 USDT.
The MLM side of Passivo pays on recruitment of affiliate investors.
Passivo Affiliate Ranks
There are twelve affiliate ranks within Passivo’s compensation plan.
Along with their respective qualification criteria, they are as follows:
- Rank 1 – sign up as a Passivo affiliate and convince others to invest $2000
- Rank 2 – convince others to invest $5000
- Rank 3 – convince others to invest $25,000
- Rank 4 – convince others to invest $50,000
- Rank 5 – convince others to invest $125,000
- Rank 6 – convince others to invest $250,000
- Rank 7 – convince others to invest $500,000
- Rank 8 – convince others to invest $1,250,000
- Rank 9 – convince others to invest $2,500,000
- Rank 10 – convince others to invest $5,000,000
- Rank 11 – convince others to invest $12,500,000
- Rank 12 – convince others to invest $25,000,000
Note that no more than 40% of required downline investment volume is counted from any one recruitment leg.
Referral Commissions
Passivo pays referral commissions on funds invested by personally recruited affiliates:
- recruit 1 to 3 affiliates and receive 0.2% a week on their invested funds
- recruit 4 to 7 affiliates and receive 0.4% a week on their invested funds
- recruit 8 to 9 affiliates and receive 0.6% a week on their invested funds
- invest 10 or more affiliates and receive 0.8% a week on their invested funds
Note that recruited affiliates must have invested in order to count.
Residual Commissions
Passivo pays a residual commission on total downline investment:
- recruit 2 to 4 affiliates and receive 0.04% a week on total downline investment
- recruit 5 to 9 affiliates and receive 0.08% a week on total downline investment
- recruit 10 to 19 affiliates and receive 0.12% a week on total downline investment
- recruit 20 or more affiliates and receive 0.16% a week on total downline investment
Pool Bonus
Passivo takes an undisclosed percentage of company-wide investment and places it into eight bonus pools.
Affiliates qualify for a share in the pools by investing and convincing others to invest:
- Pool 1 – invest $3000 or invest $1000 and convince others to invest $1000
- Pool 2 – invest $15,000 or invest $5000 and convince others to invest $5000 (must recruit 3 affiliates)
- Pool 3 – invest $30,000 or invest $7500 and convince others to invest $15,000 (must recruit 5 affiliates)
- Pool 4 – invest $60,000 or invest $10,000 and convince others to invest $35,000 (must recruit 8 affiliates)
- Pool 5 – invest $170,000 or invest $20,000 and convince others to invest $95,000 (must recruit 10 affiliates)
- Pool 6 – invest $350,000 or invest $50,000 and convince others to invest $180,000 (must recruit 13 affiliates)
- Pool 7 – invest $900,000 or invest $100,000 and convince others to invest $500,000 (must recruit 15 affiliates)
- Pool 8 – invest $1,800,000 or invest $250,000 and convince others to invest $1,000,000 (must recruit 20 affiliates)
Passivo’s marketing material omits how frequently the Pool Bonus is paid out.
Global Leader Pool
Passivo takes 0.01% of company-wide investment and places it into the Global Leader Pool.
To qualify for a share in the Global Leader Pool, a Passivo affiliate must be earning $3000 a day in residual commissions.
Passivo’s marketing material omits how frequently the Global Leader Pool is paid out.
Rank Achievement Bonus
Passivo rewards affiliates for qualifying at Rank 2 and higher with the following one-time Rank Achievement Bonuses:
- qualify at Rank 2 and receive $50
- qualify at Rank 3 and receive $250
- qualify at Rank 4 and receive $500
- qualify at Rank 5 and receive 1250
- qualify at Rank 6 and receive $2500
- qualify at Rank 7 and receive $5000
- qualify at Rank 8 and receive $12,500
- qualify at Rank 9 and receive 25,000
- qualify at Rank 10 and receive 50,000
- qualify at Rank 11 and receive $125,000
- qualify at Rank 12 and receive $250,000
Joining Passivo
Passivo affiliate membership is free.
Full participation in the attached income opportunity requires a minimum $100 investment.
Passivo solicits investment in USD and various cryptocurrencies.
Passivo Conclusion
Passivo represents it generates external revenue via “liquidity providing” and “trading opportunities”.
Liquidity Providing: By providing capital to traders on exchanges, you earn a fixed interest rate, and a portion of the capital is allocated to trading opportunities in top crypto projects, and startups.
Naturally Passivo fails to provide evidence invested funds are in fact provided to “traders on exchanges”, or that it is engaged in “trading opportunities”.
On the regulatory front, as per the Howey Test Passivo’s passive weekly returns constitutes a securities offering.
Passivo additionally fails to provide evidence it has registered its securities offering with financial regulators in any jurisdiction.
This means that, at a minimum, Passivo is committing securities fraud. Securities fraud and Ponzi schemes go hand-in-hand.
One other oddity to note is the appearance of Camhirst 3DCP in one of Passivo’s marketing videos:
Camhirst 3DCP is a non-MLM crypto Ponzi scheme:
Ahmed is another crypto bro hiding out in Dubai. Like Jan Lubberding being the obvious fall-guy for Passivo, Ahmed plays the same role in Camhirst.
It’s possible the same group of scammers are behind both companies.
As it stands, the only verifiable source of revenue entering Passivo is new investment.
Using new investment to pay affiliate withdrawals would make Passivo a Ponzi scheme.
As with all MLM Ponzi schemes, once affiliate recruitment dries up so too will new investment.
This will starve Passivo of ROI revenue, eventually prompting a collapse.
The math behind Ponzi schemes guarantees that when they collapse, the majority of participants lose money.
Update 23rd November 2023 – Passivo has collapsed.
Oz wrote:
Another website belongs to this scam: passivo.io. The domain was registered in Iceland on September 4, 2022.
The following people are named there:
Jan Lübberding – CEO
Samuel Schrodt – Project Advisor
Walter Nasse – Community Manager
share-your-photo.com/6ea6bc27e4
Manuela Hoffmann – Social Media Manager
Patrick Hummer – CMO
Markus Rossier – CSO
share-your-photo.com/c288d0005f
On YouTube, the United Arab Emirates is mentioned as the headquarters of passivo.io:
share-your-photo.com/cb64f6d3f1
youtube.com/@passivo-io/about
passivo.io on Instagram:
share-your-photo.com/62b290b80b
instagram.com/passivo.io
Jan Lübberding is a German citizen and has managed many companies. On May 27, 2022 his company Phonepapst GmbH in Friesoythe was declared insolvent:
share-your-photo.com/09d1fd63f7
companyhouse.de/Phonepapst-GmbH-Friesoythe/Insolvenzen
This reminds me of the OneCoin scam. Many insolvent entrepreneurs from Germany have tried to become liquid again with OneCoin.
Walter Nasse (Community Manager) is also German. His profile on XING:
share-your-photo.com/8b4c8445f3
xing.com/profile/Walter_Nasse2/cv
Video of June 1, 2023 with Patrick Hummer (CMO) and Markus Rossier (CSO).
The following screenshot shows Patrick Hummer:
share-your-photo.com/b4ae7e0e0a
youtube.com/watch?v=8g8X1xC_Xf8
As usual with scammers, the video was not listed and the comment function was disabled.
Addition to comment #2
The following screenshot shows that two companies of Jan Lübberding are in liquidation:
share-your-photo.com/6450c61d2f
northdata.de/L%C3%BCbberding,+Jan+Wilhelm,+Cloppenburg/18yn
One company insolvent, two companies in liquidation – will Jan Lübberding’s success story continue?
Three countries are already mentioned in connection with the Passivo scam:
Seychelles on the website passivo.io:
share-your-photo.com/11f589820b
Iceland in the domain registration:
share-your-photo.com/fdb471fd4f
United Arabic Emirates on YouTube:
share-your-photo.com/cb64f6d3f1
But in fact, the scammers live in Germany or are German. Which country follows next?
A Passivo presentation in English on Vimeo:
player.vimeo.com/video/840224088?h=8fd5a9f8cf
Markus Rossier (CSO) writes on his website majesticmarkus.com, among other things:
share-your-photo.com/b93c98c073
In his imprint he only mentions an email address because he does not want to be disturbed by phone?
share-your-photo.com/a49b37b6a4
Membership in his Telegram group costs 49.97 euros per month. Yes, even millionaires have to save, life in Dubai is said to be very expensive….
majesticmarkus.com/cryptomajestics/
Before Markus Rossier became a self-proclaimed “cryptocurrency millionaire”, he worked as a fitter in Roth, Bavaria. With this excellent education, every German fitter will also become a millionaire…. 😀
A photo of this scammer from March 2023:
share-your-photo.com/e5c407dfd4
Markus Rossier on Instagram. The account exists since March 2019, but the photos from Dubai will not start until June 2020:
share-your-photo.com/7b0e0cc650
instagram.com/markusrossier/
Thanks for the additional research Melanie.
Looks like the first victims will be from the german origin.
So far only two telegram groups which I found to be linked to the official group, with less than 700 subscribers each and all posts are in the german language offical announcement :
Addition to comment #1
Samuel Schrodt (Project Advisor) calls himself “The Money Mentor” and offers a free ebook (KRYPTO 1X1) on his website der-geldmentor.de.
share-your-photo.com/94488fe4e9
What’s funny is this sentence from the table of contents:
share-your-photo.com/c40a8e5205
der-geldmentor.de/f/dankeseite
For 4.99 euros, he offers an extended version of his ebook.
der-geldmentor.de/f/1×1-krypto
As usual with scammers, his website does not contain an imprint or other contact details, even though an imprint is mandatory for commercial websites in Germany.
His Instagram account is also private. I assume that Samuel Schrodt lives in Germany and for this reason conceals his identity.
share-your-photo.com/b24db2c357
instagram.com/samuel.schrodt/
PASSIVO – Questions and answers.
The last statement is inaccurate. Is the new cycle again 90 paydays long or longer?
share-your-photo.com/db16cf5d8d
passivo.io/#how-it-work
Two things remind me spontaneously of the OneCoin scam. These scammers also ask for personal data using KYC and the charity they claim to have, called OneWorldFoundation by Ruja Ignatova.
I am always happy when scammers are also charitable and donate to poor people.
Based on their copy, I believe any renewed cycles would be extended for another 90 days.
Addition to comment #1
Patrick Hummer (CMO) is the most active member of this group of six.
In July 2016, Patrick Hummer founded the following company in the UK with only 1,000 euros in start-up capital: LIFESTYLE COACH LTD.
share-your-photo.com/43106565f2
share-your-photo.com/7b3645e7f8
find-and-update.company-information.service.gov.uk/company/10289029
In January 2023, this company was dissolved.
Patrick Hummer is Austrian and lives in Wels. On the Internet I find two different addresses in Wels:
share-your-photo.com/3f60026f42
The following photo shows Patrick Hummer (right) with Jürgen Höller from Germany. Jürgen Höller is called trainer, motivator, coach etc. and has many customers from MLM or Network Marketing.
share-your-photo.com/a0a34d8555
Patrick Hummer claims on his current website (patrick-hummer.com) that he was a police officer before he started network marketing. One time he mentions 25 years, another time 20 years:
Patrick Hummer also claims that he has built an international network of more than 10,000 distributors and customers. Allegedly, he was the No. 1 in a network company, but he conceals which company that was. Why? Because it is a lie?
Because of a large advertising banner on his website that cannot be removed, only part of it is readable. It begins with the following words:
Because of the advertising banner, I also can’t hear what lies Patrick Hummer tells in the video on his website. Which fool made this disastrous website?
share-your-photo.com/2b8b2eb628
The imprint is also not fully legible, but his contact details are known:
patrick-hummer.com/impressum30656935
Since September 2017, his Instagram account with current link to Passivo scam exists:
share-your-photo.com/b910dda031
instagram.com/patrick.hummer.mcfly/
On the following website Patrick Hummer links to various websites:
linktr.ee/patrickhummer
Patrick Hummer on LinkedIn, reportedly self-employed since July 2016:
share-your-photo.com/83867d6203
linkedin.com/in/patrick-hummer-830348b0/?originalSubdomain=at
A promotional video for the Passivo scam on LinkedIn:
share-your-photo.com/1b09bc83db
linkedin.com/feed/update/urn:li:activity:7079387782355333120/
On LinkedIn, Patrick Hummer does not mention that he has worked for the police in the past. Why?
Patrick Hummer‘s last post on Instagram no longer exists. It contained advertising for the Passivo scam. I had saved the following link:
instagram.com/p/CuPJwdRAu0a/
Now it is displayed to me:
Patrick Hummer (CMO) is furious! 😀 People should act, not talk! He rants, but his voice is not heard, only music:
share-your-photo.com/8c19eb008e
instagram.com/p/CwsM35Do17Y/
A look at the passivo.io dashboard:
share-your-photo.com/ddf46138ff
A few of the stages in Patrick Hummer’s MLM CV:
– Vemma
– OneCoin
– Conligus
– GDI (Global Dynamics Investment Hawo Holding Inc)
– Alpha Centauri Inc.
– CTX
– Paraiba
All these stations turned out to be scams sooner or later.
At GDI, Alpha Centauri and CTX he was very close to a certain Michael Sander.
By the way: He was indeed a policeman for years, but then allegedly had to leave the job because of his MLM activities.
P.S.
all “investors” in Passivo should save enough recordings, videos and screenshots of all these German and Austrian people.
If the fraud is discovered, it is difficult to sue a letterbox company in the Seychelles …. but it is possible to sue actively involved persons like CEO, COO or CMO from Germany and Austria!
Apparently Manuela Hoffmann aka cryptorella_ is the Co-Founder of Passivo.io as stated on her instagram page:
instagram.com/cryptorella_/
She used to own a failing business called Vaporella in Friesoythe, a Town in Lower Saxony, Germany: instagram.com/_vaporella_/
She also seems to have done some Bodybuilding competitions but there are hardly any traces anymore on google.
Jan Luebberding is also from Friesoythe where he used to own a failing smartphone repair store called Phonepapst GmbH:
facebook.com/Phonepapst/ traces can also be found on google.
Mr. Luebberding’s relatives still reside in the area apparently while he pretends to be a successful entrepreneur to them.
There are multiple podcasts and videos available where he is interviewed by other MLM scam artists like Adrian Leimkühler.
Mr Leiomkühler has a podcast on Spotify: open.spotify.com/episode/5btpAo5Ts5XRRCneM3d6Vk
Very pitiful individuals altogether with a lot of criminal Energy.
Maybe someone who speaks german can listen to those podcasts an post their findings on here.
@Harold Finch
Thank you for your additional research. I read it with interest.
A few details about the podcast.
I gave away 24 minutes of my life listening to this ridiculous podcast. I learned nothing, because facts were of course not mentioned. It was the usual drivel that is common in the MLM scene.
Jan Lübberding calls himself a multi-entrepreneur and multi-millionaire, but says at the end of the video that he only invested 25,000 euros in equity for the Passivo scam.
That is the minimum amount for someone to set up a GmbH (limited liability company) in Germany. Allegedly, he borrowed another six-figure amount for founding Passivo.
In the past, he has also worked for 9 euros an hour and later selling insurances. From insurance salesman to multi-millionaire – a grandiose career!
I do not believe that a German bank has granted him a loan, because his previous companies were not successful or are insolvent (see comments #2 and 5).
Jan Lübberding does not speak like an educated entrepreneur with a university degree, but like a student who does not yet know what profession he wants to pursue one day.
share-your-photo.com/c1735edf7d
open.spotify.com/episode/5btpAo5Ts5XRRCneM3d6Vk
The German BaFin has been issuing warnings since August 9, 2023:
share-your-photo.com/4f48dda3c4
bafin.de/SharedDocs/Veroeffentlichungen/DE/Verbrauchermitteilung/unerlaubte/2023/meldung_2023_08_09_passivo.html
Thanks for the heads up on the BaFin warning Melanie.
Manuela Hoffmann the Social Media Manager of Passivo is fraud.
She has not corporate experience.
share-your-photo.com/9fa71a8bef
I know her. She a school dropout and not even no formal education. Surely no corporate experience at all. She worked in a food packing plant with me! Sorry for my bad english.
Passivo presentation German with CEO Jan Lübberding:
share-your-photo.com/f7c5cf572e
player.vimeo.com/video/837342888?h=d5ce92343e&utm_medium=social&utm_source=heylink.me
All real names and pictures in the ‘About Us’ section have been deleted now.
And perhaps someone got a little scared? 😉
Bit silly trying to hide the information when you’ve already put it out there.
Addition to comment #4.
Out of four videos on passivo.io‘s YouTube channel, only one is still visible. Three videos were either deleted or not listed!
share-your-photo.com/b66c61f3ab
youtube.com/@passivo-io/videos
Also the Austrian Financial Market Supervisory Authority (Finanzmarktaufsicht; FMA) warns not to enter any transactions with Passivo ltd
fma.gv.at/passivo-ltd/
Addition to comment #29.
The scammers from passivo.io have uploaded a fifth video, which has also not been registered:
share-your-photo.com/dc2cfdae30
youtube.com/@passivo-io/videos
Total visits last 3 months (July till September) and visitors by country on passivo.io:
share-your-photo.com/4f2fe04af6
Melanie, the 5 videos are visible. 4 of them are under the “Shorts” tab.
catweazle, I’ve seen the so-called “shorts”, but I haven’t counted them because they don’t replace videos describing passivo.io’s “business model”.
Oz wrote:
That was in August. Now the domain passivo.com can be purchased.
share-your-photo.com/f43ec89d6d
passivo.ch redirects to passivo.io/auth?refrelCode=460534.
I don’t know who owns the website.
passivo.at redirects to passivo.io/auth?refrelCode=892501
The website belongs to the well-known serial fraudster Patrick Hummer from Wels in Austria.
passivo.io on Instagram with 437 followers. The account has existed since May 9, 2023:
share-your-photo.com/c44e4f662d
instagram.com/passivo.io/